Richmond Palladium (Daily), Volume 40, Number 155, 12 June 1915 — Page 1

BIG PA AJMTUM VOL. XL , NO. 155. Palladium and Bun-Tel RICHMOND, 1NDV SATURDAY EVENING, J UNE 12, 1915. SINGLE COPY. 2 CENTS Consolidate. ltOT

U. S. DIPLOMATS SEE SOLUTION WITHGEjlMANY Officials at Capital Hear Second Note Favorably Received at Berlin and Settlement Expected.

CRITICISE SEC. BRYAN Late Statement to German Americans Believed to Em barrass Position of Country With Foreign Nations. . WASHINGTON, June 12. The United States and Germany are on the way toward an amicable and mutually honorable settlement of their grave differences. This was the accepted view today in official and diplomatic Washington. Unofficial, but credible reports have reached the capital that the second American note has been well received in Berlin, where the firmness of its tone was not overlooked, but it was noted that the document is not oora hatlA in tenor and shows the diSDOSi tion of this government to come to a reasonable oasis 01 agreement. Tuun WMkt tor Reelv. The renlv of the German foreign of fice to the American note transmitted . two days ago, is not expected for about two weeks, but there is a noticeable increase in the optimism of government officials. This more hopeful feeling regarding the controversy, howvr wii mixAd with some concern as .to the interpretation Germany and other foreign countries may put upon the propaganda sponsored by the re tired secretary or state, wuiiam j Bryan. The former premier has issued an nthr statement exDlainlng his post tinn. his latest anneal being addressed to German-Americans, who are asked to use their influence upon tne German crnvernment to Dersuade it not to take any step which may lead to war. Criticise Bryan. Reran of his recent utterances at a critical period in the nation's history Mr. Bryan has not escaped severe criticism, and it is understood that his activities at this time are not wholly understood or pleasing to omciai Washington. .While Germany considers the second American note, it became known in nffida.1 auarters that this govern ment will send to Great Britain and her allies a note seeking a change in the cenduct of the "bread blockade" now conducted by them. It will be urged that such a blockade should be conducted along the recognized principles of international law which forbid interference with non-contraband articles in transist to or from a belligerent country through continguous neutral territory or destined to neutral , ports. BRITISH PRESS PRAISES NOTE OF PRESIDENT LONDON, June 12. President Wilson's stand against Germany's submarine warfare in the name of humanity and the text of the second American note of protest to the Kaiser's government, are highly praised by British newspapers today. It is noticeable that the tone of the press toward the United States and toward President Wilson in particular is becoming much more cordial than it was earlier In the war. "The American note is not the stinging document that it was expected to be but a second reading of it gives the impression of a deep feeling carefully restrained and the lofty sense of duty which one great neutral power owes to humanity," says the Evening Standard. The Pall Mall Gazette says "President Wilson is clearly determined that if Germany would furnish a rupture she would do so with the colors of piracy firmly nailed to the flagstaff." The Globe declares that by the resignation of Bryan the United States is rid of an influence which jeopardized its power as a nation. The Globe, which has been noted by its anti-American attitude, approves the note. TO HOLD OUTING. Economy, Ind., June 12. Spiritualists will hold a basket meeting at Sunflower park, Sunday, June 20. Weather Forecast For Indiana Probably showers to- , night and Sunday. Warmer tonight northeast portion. Temperature. Noon 83 Yesterday. Maximum t.t.... 80 Minimum 62 For Richmond Continued warm tonight and Sunday. Occasional thundershowers. GENERAL CONDITIONS The grea GENERAL CONDITIONS The great area of low barometric pressure west of the Mississippi river is causing warm weather which will continue for the next 86 hours with occasional rains. , W. E. MOORE, Weather Forecaster.

MANY FLAGS BOUGHT

Satisfactory results were being ob tained today through the sale of minlatue flags by the members of the Worn an's Relief Corps who occupied various stands along Main street and solicited funds to be used during the ensuing year for relief work. Between three thousand and thirty five hundred flags were on hand for disposal and though the members of the relief corps at noon today had no way of estimating the total amount which had been received, yet they were of the opinion that many had been sold to passers-by. . BRYAN STANDS READY TO GIVE CRITICS REPLY Former Secretary of State Will Not Let Censure Go Unanswered According to Statement. WASHINGTON, June 12. William J. Bryan today made it clear that he is on the firing line to defend his pol icy and will not permit criticism of his course to go' unheeded. He an' nounced that he would issue a statement tonight to correct "two mistaken statements which have gained circula tion." Mr. Bryan' outlined his immediate plan in the following statement: "The next two weeks will be largely devoted to rest. During the two years and three months which have elapsed since I entered the state department I have had but little vacation, considerably less than the time which the law allows to all govern ment employes. If an historian is interested enough to examine the rec ord he will find that no former secretary of state has been at his desk a greteer number of hours each day for a greater number of days in the year snri T nm kui-a that vaia mv mAHA ceBsors naa to aeai witn more proDlems of the first magnitude. it nas Deen a long and severe strain and Mrs. Bryan has shared it with me. We both feel the need of rest and shall avail ourselves of this opportunity to secure it. We shall go to Old Point Comfort tonight to spend Sunday and Monday and return Tues day morning. By that time we shall have our plans matured for the re mainder of June and possibly, for a longer period. Mr. Bryan would not elaborate on his statement today which was viewed as a reply to those who-have criticised his absence from the desk on lecturing tours and for other purposes. On his return Tuesday morning Mr. Bryan will issue another statement but said he did not intend to forecast its tenot today. QUESTION OF TAXES FOR LIBRARY'S USE BROUGHT TO BOARD The Question of a tax increase for the Morrisson-Reeves library is again facing the township library board. The board 1b undecided whether to increase the tax to five cents or risk an inadequate tax return on a four cent levy. In the last few months, repairs amounting to $600, have been made. The repairs were paid for with an advance fro mthis year's taxes. A year ago, a house on North Sixth street, next to the library building, was purchased, and repairs have been made on it recently. There is a good rental income from the Investment. It is understood some of the members believe the library has been popularized in the last year through the efforts of the librarian and Charles N. Sanborn of the state library board, and for this reason an increased tax is believed satisfactory to the public. The books have been made available to the township residents, also contributors to the library tax, through the township schools. Probably no recommendation will be made to the township advisory board when it meets Monday. The board has other important matters, including the sale of $12,000 in school bonds. The bonds are expected to bring a good premium. They have been issued to pay for two new school houses under course of construction. FEE6ER TO WELCOME LUTHERAN DELEGATES Rev. A. J. Feeger, pastor of St. John's Lutheran church, will deliver the address of welcome and Rev. Mr. Schillinger of West Alexandria will respond on behalf of the delegates at the annual convention of the Luther League which will be held in Richmond at St. John's church Sunday afternoon and evening. Plans have been perfected for the convention to which 250 delegates are expected. Miss Altha Becker of West Alexandria will speak on "How to Advance the Spirituality of Our Young People' and Miss Daisy Summers will speak on "The Function of the Luther League at the afternoon session. Rev. G. A. Pfleuger of Farmersville, Ohio, M. L. Braum, Albert Schell, of West Alexandria and Rev. Joseph Beck of Rich mond are also on the afternoon pro gram. Rev. O. Tressel of Dayton will deliver the sermon in the evening and oth ers on the program for that service are: Rev. Mr. Ridenour of New Lebano nand Rev. Weber oj Eaton, Ohiov

RUSSIANS SLAY

WHOLE DIVISION OF TEUTON FOE Petrograd Claims Victory Over Gen von Linsingen's Army on Dniester River in Galicia. . OFFICERS WOUNDED Germans and Austrians in Fierce Drives About Shavli Fall in Heaps Before Wire Entanglements. PETROGRAD, June 12. A whole Austro-German division was wiped out in the defeat of the army of General on Linsingen on the Dniester in Galicia. The right wing of the Teutonic army in Galicia has been outflanked. Six thousand Austrians and Germans ar ereported to have been killed In the battle between Prezmysl and Lemberg. During an artillery duel in that quarter, a German general commanding a division was wounded and twelve other officers of high rank were struck by fragments of a shell which,! exploded near by. Further important successes for the Kussians an along tne line are announced in an official statement is sued by the Russian war office today. In the northern sphere of operations, from the Dubissa river to Beissagola, the Russians have definitely assumed the offensive. Attempts of the Austro-German army of General von Mackensen to push eastward from Mosciska to Lvov (Lemberg) have been stopped short by the Russians. The Austro-German army of General von Linsenger, whose drive northward toward Lemberg, was checked on the east bank of the Dniester river has been compelled to retire, giving up much booty to the pursuing Russians. East of the Stryj the whole of the fifth company of the 79th Austrian regiment was captured. The official communique follows: "On Thursday night and yesterday, the Germans, after a furious bombardment, renewed their determined attacks from the west of Shavli, on the front of Kulje lake, Radiewo and Elnoraltsy. During the night the Germans on several occasions reached the barbed wire entanglements in front of our trenches. However, every assault was thrown back by our fire and the Germans in Tetirlng left piles of killed and wounded upon the field behind them. "In the region north of Shavli an enemy detachment, composed principally of cavalry, advanced slightly in the direction of Shaklnovo. coming from the west. "On the left bank of the Dubissa, from Shavli to Beissagola, we have assumed the offensive." OLD TRAIL BOOSTERS PLAN ENTERTAINMENT Dr. I. S. Harold has sent the following suggestions to townships: It would be well for each township to hold at an early date in a conveni ent place meetings for the purpose of conferring together and make the pre liminary arrangements for joining in the parade and attending the Fourth of July celebration. A strawberry and ice cream festival using flowers and flags for decorations could be used as the social feature of the occasion. These conferences should be attended by men, women and children from all parts of the township. Notice of such meetings should be sent put at the earliest possible date to all parts of the township. CITIZENS TO DISCUSS L. H. & P. PURCHASE The first open meeting In which citizens will be permitted to discuss the light plant purchase question freely will be held Monday night, the regular Commercial club meeting being given for the purpose. George Seidel, chairman of the committee which returned a negative report to the city officials on the purchase of the Light, Heat and Power electric holdings will preside and lead In the discussions. Secretary Haas, said today he expects a large attendance at the meeting. General business will be transacted from 7:30 to 8 o'clock and at 8 o'clock. Dr. David W. Dennis will report on the World's Court Conference in Cleveland. Following his report, the light plant problem will become the topic of discussion and members will be permitted to go on record for or against the purchase. FOOS SEEKS ELECTION EATON, O., Jun 12. Although he announced be would not be a candi date for re-election, Mayor Stanley B. Foos has cast his hat into the ring and is seeking nomination on the Dem ocratic ticket. The Republican candidate for nomination is George H. Kel ly, who was defeated two years ago by Foos. A decided lull is noticeable among office seekers, and several have failed to draw out applicants for nomination. Six councilmen will be nominated in the August primaries, but there are only three aspirants in each party an nounced. They are F. R. Christman, John W. Harris and T. W. Gates, Democrats; G. W. Longnecker, J. O. Welsh and E. E. Morrow. These six are at I P.reBen geryjog In thflt body.

MALE OPENS LAST EXERCISES FOR GRADUATES Entertainment by Literary Societies Includes Numbers by Glee and Madrigal 'Singing Clubs.

TRUSTEES TO MEET Alumni Will Assemble to Open Ballots for Three Places on College Board Before Commencement. Although the under classes of Earlham are in the midst of final examinations, -the first event of commencement week took place last evening when Miss Laura Gaston, head of the music department. Miss Carolyn Hutton and Glenn Frlermood, held their annual joint recital of pupils. A public entertainment is scheduled for this evening at 8 o'clock, and will be under the auspices of the Ionian and Phoenix Literary societies. The entertainment is to take the place , of the usual play, which was abolished this year because of . the many other interests at the college that prevented the selection of a suitable cast. Among the features of the entertainment this evening will be the special numbers by the Glee club and the Madrigal club. The public speak ing' department will also have a part in the program. Thirty-nine candidates will receive A. B. degrees Wednesday morning at the commencement exercises. Four master of arts degrees will be awarded. The class this year is not as large as the graduating class last year, but is above the average in grades. To Deliver Sermon. The baccalaureate sermon will be delivered in the chapel Sunday morn ing at 10:30 o'clock by Dr. Thomas Nicholson of New York, corresponding secretary of the board Of education of the Methodist Episcopal church. Sun day evening a joint meeting of the Y. M. C. A. and Y. W. C. A. will be addressed by Dr. David Worth Dennis At the meeting of the board of trus tees Monday morning it is expected that recommendations for the employment of professors to take the place of those who have resigned this year will be made by President Xelly. No official announcement has been made by President Kelly who will succeed Prof. Elbert Russell in the Biblical department, but it is probable that Prof. W. O. Mendenhall will be placed at the head of the department. Among the men who are being considered is Alexander Purdy, son of Proffl Ellison Purdy, of Wilmington, O., who has been a frequent visitor at the college, and has conducted religious meetings there. Other resignations that will be considered at the board meeting are those of Prof. Haile in the classi cal department; Rev. M. S. Kenworthy of the Biblical department; Miss Gladys Bassett, head of girls' athletics, and Miss Elizabeth Conrad, who has asked for a year's leave of absence. The Alumni and Old Students' asso ciations hold their annual meetings Tuesday afternoon. These two asso ciations will hold their meetings joint ly. Edward D. Evans of Indianapolis, is president of the association; Prof, B. W. Kelly is vice president; Miss Barbara Beckman of Richmond is sec retary, and Miss Frances Wright of Richmond is treasurer. The ballots which have been sent to all the alumni of the college asking for their vote on the three men to be added to the board of trustees of the college, will be opened at this meeting Tuesday afternoon at 2 o'clock. Great interest is centered around this event, as it will show definitely what stand the alumni of the college are taking to ward the Kelly-Russell controversy, which was thrashed out at the trus tees' meeting a month ago. At that time, it was insisted by the Kelly sup porters in the board of trustees, that the alumni of the college are in ma jority support of the present administration. This vote will show definitely, for. an active campaign has been waged by both the Russell and Kelly factions to elect their respective supporters to the board and thus destroy the balance of power now held by President Kelly. Commencement exercises will be held at 10 o'clock Wednesday morn ing. Dr. William D. MacClintok, pro fessor of English literature of Chicago university will make the commencement address. REFUSES TO PUBLISH BRYAN'S STATEMENTS - ATLANTA, Ga., June 12. The Atlanta Constitution today in an editorial says that William J. Bryan is a public nuisance, and that no more of his statements, will be published in that newspaper. The editorial says: "Mr. Bryan's continued statements at this particular juncture make him nothing less than a public nuisance. With full confidence in President .Wilson's ability to handle the situation, the Constitution does not Intend that this work shall be embarrassed or that the country shall be made to appear divided before the world by continued publication of what Mr. Bryan may have to say. Whether intentionally so or not, the statements of Mr. Bryan are timed in such a manner as . to cause the greatest embarrassment of the president In a most delicate sltua-

ITALIANS TAKE

ORE CITIES ROMS, June 12. With the Austrian cities of Monfalcone Gradizca and Roverto, as well one hundred Tillages In Italian possession and the Italians drives against the Austrian stronghold of Trent and Trieste proceeding successfully, the Austrian troops are becoming completely demoralized by continuous defeats. An official statement bearing upon the phase of the Austro-Italian war was given out today by the Italian general staff. HOLE PRESIDES AT PEACE TALK BY DR. JORDAN Hon. William Dudley Foulke Will Introduce Noted Peace Advocate Who Speaks at Coliseum. Dr. David Starr Jordan, chancellor of Leland-Stanford university, California, who will deliver a complimen tary lecture on "Peace and War" at 2:30 o'clock Sunday afternoon, is expected to arrive In Richmond either tonight or tomorrow morning. No word has been received from him by William Dudley Foulke, at whose home he will be a guest during his 6tay in this city. The executive committee for the Jordan meeting announced that all arrangements had been completed, in cluding the program which is given below. The doors of the Coliseum will be open at 1:30 o'clock. Following Is the program: Chairman Dr. Allen D. Hole Solo Mrs. F. W. Kreuger. Invocation.. Rev. J. S. Lightbourn, St. Paul's Episcopal Church Duet "Twilight" Nevin Mrs. Bartel and Mrs. Igelman. Introduction of Dr. Jordan Hon. William Dudley Foulke Address Dr. David Starr Jordan Song "Great Peace Have They Which Love the Law" Rogers Mrs. Charles Igelman. Benediction Dr. Conrad Huber, St. Paul's Lutheran Church WAR IN POLAND ON BIG SCORE BERLIN, June 12. Hostilities have developed on a big scale in Poland, where the Germans have won two important fights at Pzasnysz and the other at Sochaszew, west of Warsaw. The German war office in an, official statement today declared that 650 Russians had been taken and that the Slav position had been broken. The Austro-German army of General Von Liningen has engaged the Russians that were advancing against his left wing in Galicia. A mighty conflict has been raging around Zurowano, the town having changed hands twice. The Russians have been driven beyond the bridge at Mienska. At Prazasnysz the Russians were driven from a strong position and lost 150 prisoners as well as machine guns and mine throwers. In the western theatre French and British attacks were repulsed near Ypres and near the Dorette hills. The French, heavily reinforced, attacked Labrynth, but were repulsed. OPEN COMMERCIAL CLUB TO WOMEN CENTERVILLE, Ind., June 12. Robert Peele, editor of the National Road Traveler, -conferred with members of the Commercial club regarding the establishment of a weekly paper here. Further action will be taken after thorough investigation of the proposition. The constitution was amended to open membership to women and to induce them to affiliate with the organization. WAVERLY KNIGHTS HOLD DECORATION EATON, Ohio, June 12 With Impressive ceremonies, the graves of fifty-nine departed members of the Knights of Pythias fraternity will be decorated Sunday afternoon by Waverly lodge of this city. Members of the order will form a line at the temple and march to the cemetery, headed by the Commercial Club band. Following the rendition of the ritualistic service on the K. of P. lot a program will be carried out at the speaker's stand. Judge Edward- Bolz, of Newport, Ky.. will be present and deliver the chief address. MAKE UP LIST OF AUTO OWNERS A list of automobile owners willing to take delegates to the convention ot the State Association of Stationary Engineers to manufacturing centers ot the city, is being made up by the Commercial club. There will be 125 to 150 delegates. Part of the exhibits which will be shown in Eagles hall, have arrived The convention will open Tuesday. GRANTED DIVORCE Will Sichler was granted a divorce in circuit court today from Bessie Sichler on grounds of desertion. The plaintiff said he married in 1910 and hia wife left him in 1913.- .

RUMELY PLflHT SPENT 81 .1 5 TO ME MD SELL GOODS VALUED AT 81 Excessive Cost Causes Failure of Corporation Dr. Rcaely and Associates in Working Factories to Capacity Piled Up Goods and Fail to Regard Demand for Goods Among Farmers Machines Pile Up Over-supply Fills Warehouses While Market Is Glutted with Goods.

SUPPLY MUCH GREATER THAN FARMERS MEED At End of First Year Management Learns Usual Factory Cost of Fifty Cents for Every Dollar's Worth of Macluacry Produced Had Been Increased to 78 Cents, While Selling Cost Added 37 Cents More, Making a Total Cost of $1.15 for Each Dollar's Worth of Product

AMERICAN NOTE CONSIDERED BY GERMAN OFFICE Von Jagow and Foreign Office Consider Document But Take no Steps Toward Replying. KAISER GETS COPY Answer May be Held Off Until July Awaiting Arrival of and Conference With Gerhard. BERLIN, June 12. Although the second American note relative to Germany's submarine war Is now. under consideration by Foreign Minister von Jagow and the attaches of the foreign office, no steps will be taken toward the framing of a reply until Emperor William returns from the front. The Kaiser already knows the con tents of the note, a copy having been telegraphed to Mm by the foreign minister shortly after it was delivered by Ambassador James W. Gerard on Friday. Wait for Envoy. It may be some time in July before a reply is sent to Washington, according to the Vossische Zeitung. It is expected that the German government will wait to confer with Dr. Meyer Gerhard, personal envoy of Count Bernstorff, tne German ambassador to the United States before drafting its reply. In official and semi-official circles there is a good deal of opposition against granting the demand of Presi dent Wil6on for assurances of the safety of Americans traveling upon ships owned by nations against which Germany is at war. Pessimism regarding the possiblity of continued friendly relations between this country and the United States seems to be growing. The Berliner Zeitung, in comment ing upon the situation, sneers at exSecretary of State Bryan, calling him a "peace prophet with a voice full of unction," who wants peace with everyone, including Mexico, except Germany. "Europe, Asia and Africa are at war against Germany," says the Berliner Zeitung, "but if Mr. Bryan had had his way America would have joined in." FIND LOYND'S BODY; SAILED WITH WIFE ABOARD LUSITANIA With the receipt of a letter saying the body of her brother-in-law, David A. Loynd of Liverpool was recovered fifty miles from the spot where the Lusitania sank on May 7, Miss Mary Grimshaw, 134 South Fifteenth 6treet, has given up all hope that her sister's body will ever be taken from the sea. Mr. and Mrs. Loynd left Richmond the latter part of April and sailed on the Lusitania although warned before leaving that ships sailing for English ports were in danger of German submarines. They were urged by Mrs. Belle Thompson, whose home they were visiting and Miss Grimshaw, Mrs. Loynd's sister, to remain in Richmond. The body of Mr. Loynd was recevered fifty miles east of the sinking May 21. according to the letter. Rela tives took charge and funeral services were held in Liverpool where Mr. Loynd had purchased a merchandise store. Miss Grimshaw early gave up hope that the two would be saved. Because of Mr. Loynd's refusal to recognize fear and confidence that he and his wife would be rescued from any diffi culties, Miss Grimshaw said she believed the two would not prepare to forestall danger if it were imminent. Mr. Loynd preached' for some time at the north end mission to accommodate the members there while the regular pastor was absent. His last sermon there was In April.

After a conference with the receiver and member of the credit, ore' committee. The Palladium la able to give the first explanation In print of why the M. Rumely company failed.

A total cost of $1.15 for every dollar's worth ot machinery manufactured. That is the Btorv of tta fallnr nt the M. Rumely company, a corporation organized two and one-half years ago. ior tne purpose of controlling the American threshing machine Industry. This interesting and amazing story is soon to be told in detail, a thorough investigation of the company's affairs having been practically completed by the receiver, Finley P. Mount, of Indianapolis, and the creditors' committee. The Palladium is now in a position to present facts pertaining to the principal causes for the failure of the Immense corporation, as ascertained by the investigators. Richmond people are, of course, vitally Interested in the discoveries made by Mr. Mount and the creditors' committee, because as a result of the failure, what was once the city's largest manufacturing plant, has stood idle for many months, a forlorn monument to the unwise, impractical management of Dr. Rumely and his close associates. .Merge Large Concerns. In effecting the organization of the threshing machine combination, four of the largest threshing machine manufacturing companies in the United States were purchased by the Rumely interests and merged with their plant at Laporte, Ind. Dr. Rumely had a theory that If the five plants were each brought up to 100 per cent efficiency it would be possible to put on the market products of the total value of $22,000,000. This he proceeded to do, and during the first year of the operation of the combine every one of the five plants were hives of industry and activity. But in operating the plants at their full capacity Dr. Rumely and his associates made their first and most serious mistake. In turning out their products they failed to take into consideration the demands of the market. , - It has been ascertained that while the Rumely corporation was manufac turing its $22,000,000 of products there existed a demand for not more than $8,000,000 worth of threshing machin ery and side line agricultural imple ments the corporation specialized in. This discovery dawned upon the Rumelys when they found all their available storage places at each plant filled to capacity with no machinery, and no opportunity to market it. At the end of the first and very disastrous year of the corporation's existence the management was also startled by the discovery that instead of the usual factory cost of 50 cents for every dollar's worth of machinery produced, this cost had been 78 cents. To this they had to add a 37 cent selling cost, making a total cost of $1.15 for each dollar's worth of products. The heavy sales cost was incurred by the management in its desperate effort to unload the oversupply of ma chinery, three times the amount that farmers had been in the market for. Richmond people who marveled at the sight of new machinery standing about streets and alleys in the vicin ity of the Gaar-Scott plant during the first year of its operation under the Rumely management will now understand that these machines constituted a part of the oversupply which had drugged the machinery market. These machines stood in streets and alleys because there were no places for them in the bulging storage houses. PULLIAM SUPPLANTS JUDGE ELI REDMAN ROCKVILLE. Ind.. June 12. Charles Pulliam. Republican, today was declared legally elected judge ot the Vigo circuit court by Judge Kunkel in circuit court here, when the contest case brought by Pulliam against Eli H. Redman, came to a sudden end. Attorneys for Redman, who Is now in Leavenworth for election frauds, introduced no witnesses but asked the court to dismiss the proceedings on various technicalities. The court declared the evidence overwhelming and that Pulliam was the elected and qualified judge of Vigo county. The court found Pulliam's majority 601. the returns following the election was ten votes. Redman's attorney said lie would ask for a new trial. - -