Jasper County Democrat, Volume 10, Number 18, Rensselaer, Jasper County, 3 August 1907 — JUDGE’S CHARGE FREED HIM [ARTICLE]

JUDGE’S CHARGE FREED HIM

Governor Gooding Surprised—Others Must Stand Their Trials. Tlie probability of a verdict of acquittal in the ease of the secretarytreasurer and acknowledged leader of the Western Federation of Miners had peen freely predicted since Judge Fremont Wood read his charge, which was regarded as strongly favoring the defense in its interpretation of the laws of conspiracy, circumstantial evidence and the corroboration of an accomplice who confesses. Among the jurors the judge's charge was very effective, Samuel D. Gilman, the last man to be won over to the defense, declared that a majority of the men seemed convinced that the general tone of the court's instructions indicated that the defendant should be freed, and this is corroborated by the remarks of others of the jury. MoReau voted consistently for acquittal Horn the first, holding that the judge's instructions settled all doubt as to the course he should-take. It was also freely predicted that in the event of Haywood's acquittal the state would abandon the prosecution of his associates, Moyer and Pettibone. Statements from counsel and from Governor Gooding dispel this view or the situation. Governor Gooding said; “The verdict is a great surprise to me. and I believe to all citizens of Idaho who have heard or read the evidence in the case. I have done my duty. I have no regret as to any action I have taken, and my conscience is clear. As long as God gives me strength I shall continue m.v efforts for government by law and for organized society. The state will continue a vigorous prosecution of Moyer and Pettibone and Adams, and of Simpkins when apprehended. There will be neither hesitation nor retreat” Not the least Interesting of the comments made upon the verdict was that of Harry Orchard. When told at the state penitentiary that Haywood had been acquitted Orchard said: “Well. I have done my duty. I hare told tin truth. I could do no more. lam ready to take any punishment that may be meted out to me for my crime, and the sooner it comes the better.” Haywood Issued a statement In which he said: “I appreciate the support of the working class extended ts

country. I bope to be able during the coming year to personally express that appreciation. * • i* I wish to express appreciation of the wonderful support given to me by the presence In the court room during the trial of the representatives of labor, industrial and political organizations." . <