Indiana Palladium, Volume 8, Number 16, Lawrenceburg, Dearborn County, 5 May 1832 — Page 1
Terms $3 Pi:R YEAR 33i PER CENT. DISCOUNT MADE OX ADVANCE, Oil 10! ON HALF YEARLY PAYMENTS
VOIi. 111,
t . -A IS GTsX JTj! Vi V Hi SBtJ JJ.aXJ J2.J3LQ VJJLXai CT-TU. Ji. U JAa-JIViX. - 5 J-iJ-C-i. -3L W O ,J
I - i mi -iiririrrnifinrrii r-irnrn-t- tuti i--wiiTTrr i r-r--mtr' i '-vrrM-irir if'ifiiriMriTiia'Yiii ,trrm's
'-fT'wfct'-l
Congressional Analysis. From the Globe Arair, 19. In the Senate yesterday, Mr. I)aT.T.A?, introduced, on leave, a hill supplementary to the act for the punishment of certain crimes against ihe United States, which was twice read and referred to the Committee on the Judiciary. The bill providing for the vaccination of Indian?, with a view to prevent the ravages of the small Tox among them was taken up; and, after a long discussion, the hill underwent some modifications, and was ordered to a third reading, by a vote of 20 to 11. Mr. Fot:svth submitted a motion to re-consider the vote of yesterday, .by which the appropriation for the expenses of the United States' Courts was reduced, and it was laid on the table. The bill exempting vessels from Portugal from the operation of the law imposing certain discriminating duties, was considered and ordered to a third read-
Iv excited bv these provocations, and that tin-1 consequences of speaking boldly but when f whether a member lias a right to make one
mir.
der the influence of feelings thus excited, he travels out of the record when he uses
he did, on accidentally meeting the said j his station before the public as a means of Stanberry, assault and beat him. the accused j wilful slander and wanton detraction, he is being unarmed with any other weapon than j as liable as any other citizen; How docs a common walking cane, and believing the i that compare with the present case? A re.
. i j .
speech on this tlooi, and write out and pub-
being no longer necessary to defray Hie expenses of the government, may not be ben-
lish to the world another entirely thfkrent? ' ericiallv appropriated to some other nhiprt
This was a common practice in this place. ! Before "indicating any precise object, thev Are the public presses sprinkled with Con- j advert to the important duty, incident to it gressional unction? .We should consider government, of husbanding "the resources of
said Stanberry to be. as he in fct was arm-i port w?s before this House from the J udi- j the consequences, me members oi the j a country in times of prosperity and peace, ed with pistols that the meeting took place ciary Committee, praying to bedischarged present Congress, worn no doubt, too wise j so as to be ready to meet those adverse vicisseveral hours after the adjournment of Con-1 from an enquiry into the truth of a certain j and discreet to abuse their privileges hut i situdes from which all history shows that
res?, about 8 o'clock in the evening, on I alhdant ol a removed inspector of the cus- j it the preceaent is now established, they , no nation is exempt. "As the proceeds of
might be abused in less favorable periods ot j the sales of public lands are not wanted for
future time. He couid perceive no reason ! ordinary revenues which will be abundant-
tho Pennsylvania Avenue, and nearly half j torn. at Wiscasset, in Maine, on the ground a miie from the Capitol; and on the opposite that it was a subject within the peculiar scope side of the Avenue from where Mr. Stanber- j of the duties of the Treasury Department. rys boarding-house is situated; and that at While that report was under discussion, the the time of this occurrence, he was neilh- i member from Ohio, Mr. Stanberry, rose
why Congress should arrogate to itself an immunity denied to the rest of the world.
Such pretensions might become matter of
was
er seeking for, nor expecting to sec the said i in his place, and without any connexion or j alarm to tiieir constituents. Th Stanberry. 3 I allusion to the subject before the House, another matter upon which it woul Tho accused denies that he intended to j made a statement, that Gen. Houston had j sirablo to have information how fa
riierc
ould be de-
r a per-
ly supplied from the imports, the committee respectfully recommended that an appropria-
j tion oi them be made for some other purpos-
S OS lor a limiteri tiinr nrn in .-.- rpcimot in
the contingency of war.1' hi such an event they might be applied to the prosecution of
commit, or that lie believed he was corn- ! endeavored to practice a stupendous fraud i son was pumsnabie wno enahenged a mem- J the war, or to paying any debt tnat may mining, anv contempt towards the House j on the Government. This accusation had ber of Congress. V. e had recently several have been contracted for its prosecution; of Representatives, or anv breach of its pri- nothing to do with the subject then before i bloodless instances of that kind of figuring and on the return of porce, and payment of vile we, nr tho nriviloc-p of anv of it members. ; the House. Do the privileges of the House ! in the newspapers. But if a rijht to dial-; the war debt the fund might be again applied
In tiie House oj ueprcseniautrs, iur. VvrAsiiixfiTO from the Committee on tlie District cf Columbia reported a bill changing tire time of holding the Courts in the Dis trie. Mr. Tavloi: from the Select Committee on Patents, reported a bill concerning patents for useful inventions. Mr. I'luminer resumed his speech upon the motion to discharge the Judicimry Committee from the consideration ofthe Wiscasset case, which ho continued till the expiration ofthe hour allotted to morning business. Mr. C. Jonxsox offered a resolution authorizing General Houston to introduce counsel upon the lloor to assist in his defence, which wss agreed to. Mr. Pattox oilered a resolution directing that the testimony of the case of Gen. Houston should not he published in the newspapers during the pendency ofthe trial, which after a discussion in which Messrs. Wayne. McDrrrir, .Davis, Drayton'., A Renin. Wilpe, and Pattox took part, was withdrawn by the mover. General Houston was then introduced into the House, attended by Mr. Key, his counsel. He w:is arraigned by the Speaker. General Houston then otTered a paper to the Honse, which was sent to the t-TEAKXE, who decided that it must be read by the accused or hrs counsel. It. protested against the jurisdiction ofthe House, and requested leave as a preliminary step, to make a motion to the House. Leave Mir. Kev stated, in sub-
stance, that the accused was arraigned for a trial the rcsidt of which might involve his 2;orior and personal liberty that a fair and imoartiul trial should be awarded by the House. That his case should not bo prejudged bv the tribunal who were to decide it. That a member of the House had formed and delivered an opinion unfavorable to the accused. His motion was that the gentleman who had formed and expressed this opinion might be withdrawn from the ultimate decision of the case. The Speakeii directed the motion to be reduced to writing. It was then read fcby thcrClcrk. Mr. McDuffie moved that the accused and his counsel be conducted from the Bar while the motion was under consideration, which was carried, Ayes 91, Noes o An animated debate ensued on the
motion which had been offered in behalf of
Gen. Houston, in which Messrs. Jrvix, Ckawforp, McDuffie, Ellsworth, J. Davis, Cassxc. DoddiudoE; Deaiikorx, Au-
W. Thompson, Hckges, ana oivde,
t, when Mr. Akcher remarked that
he understood a message had been received from the accused, expressing a wish to witudraw the motion. Leave was given to
motion, uenerai iiousiou
again introduced
or the p
He denies that the act complained of con- ' not only protect a member irom the legal
stitutcs any such contempt or breach of i consequences of slander, but do they bind privilege, and is prepared to justify his con- j down and suppress those angry passions duct, so far at least as the rights and privi- ! which arc excited by wanton provocation? leges of this House and its members are j Tho House must have come to tiiis concluconcerned, by proof. 1 sion, or they have engaged in a very unThe Speaker then propounded the se-! profitable business. He did not believe the cond interrogatory as follows: j House possessed this power of restraining "Do you "admit or deny that the same J consequences of wilfully exciting the irasciassault and beating were done for and on j ble feelings of mankind. He did not bcaccountof words spoken by said Stanberry j lieve in the sacredness of the station of a in the House of Representatives in do- ! Member of Congress which relieves him bate?'' from all the human responsibilities with To which Gen. Houston made the follow-1 which other men are surrounded. A seat
i
ing reply: I consider
lenge exists, what becomes ot the conse-1 to -ome suitable object rather than that cf
quenccs. May a common citizen accept a j the ordinary cxpe'ires of government, challenge from a member of Congress ? It j In regard to the specific appropriation of must have occurred to every person who has j the fund, under ihe restriction stated, the maattended this House, cither on the floor or in i joritv of the convince recommend that afthe gallery, that in certain cases where per-! ter deducting tf:e fen percent, for the new sonal character had been introduced, some-1 States, the residue of the fund should be dithing was necessary to check the exuberance I vided ir.r five vars anion" the twenty-four of debate. These cases were altogether j States. ac r uling to their Federal Hepresenaside from the constitutional tlutics oftheitative number to be applied to Education, House. Our legislative duties would not j Internal improvements, Colonization or the once in half a century give occasion to such j redemption of debts incurred for purposes of scenes as have been witnessed on this floor J Internal Improvement, jis e.icli state judging within a few days past This House was ts- j for Jtself, inny prefer; A table is appended
t on this floor did not place an individual so ! semblcd for the purpose of making laws, i to the repor:, showing what would be the
the answer already rendered entirely above the rest of the world as to j and not for selection of victims for iinmola-; dividend o:'each State. A portion of tho
to tne first interroi
answer to the secoiu
rrojatorv, as embracing an relieve him from the necessity of redressing tion, except by the constitutional proceeding committee; says the report, were for applyolld. " j the personal wrongs he mav inflict on others. : f impeachment. Suppose at some future i ing the above residue to the objects
On motion of Mr. J. Davis, further pro-; If we may not be called on to repair inju- j day when corruption snah become general, ; of Intern:;! Improvement,
-day at V2 ! nes, we should be careful not to inflict ! an" " always commences lirst among li;ose on z.ng the tree oncics, u
cecdings were postponed till to
o clock. A discussion relative to
admit- i them. Yet in the course of a discussion are fed on the pap
of the
nd of col-
nder tho di-
Treasurv, ! rection ofthe General Government.
ting Gen. Houston to bail, took place upon ! now depending wc have witnessed an un-; rather than among the plain and hardy yco- The committee conclude their labors by
a resolution olYercd by Mr. Co:;.er, which was withdrawn, and the House adjourned.
Case oi" Grcn. fiioustoia. Remarks of Mr. Fitzgerald, of Tenncs-
pai-alleled latitude of personal remark. This j maniy--suppose a gentleman by long at-! rcjiortmg a bill entitled, an act to approprtlicense, and this immunity could not exist ! tendance as a member cf this body should j ate for "a U:nifed time, ike proceeds ofthe
together. If a member of Congress should acquire attachments oi an amorous character .?.' of t.ie ritUlic Lands of hie L mted
think proper in his place on this floor to slander the wives and daughters ofthe citizens of this district, there should be means
see, on a motion to discharge Gen. Houston ! of redress either by law, or by personal chasfrom the custody of the Sergeant at Arms. tisenicnt. The people of this country will ,T r, -j ,i w t t not permit a privileged order of men to place
PrCSeilL UCCasioiJ, muuu in i uch aiiu iuu- ; . i . lW . ' . . J . . nnfl oprsonal accoiintabib
acting in the double j , . . . , , Tf , t. that had been taken by Lie II
in mis city anu some iikciv cinvalrotus : Mates. young man should cross his patii and cclis- i
them would such an
ion ensues between
Till; PUBLIC LANDS.
liar situation it was
interference be a breach of privilege ? We ! The report on' the subject of public land3, have examples of this sort in the Roman j by Mr. Clay, is a production cf much ability : History, which produced the most important ' and at this juncture of time, of great interest.
themselves beyond the sanction of all law i consequences, fcir, we arc sent hero to act ! As the period is at hand wheiv the public
litv. The step i for the peopie within a certain prescribed j debt must be totally extinguishedthe dis-
sphere. U henevcr we go beyond that limit ; position of the public lands becomes a sub-
House in the rs-
wc act for ourselves. When members of
.1 - . 1 - & J l. , , 1 , I srvtion of this invioiabih v was premature
where tnere was no law to guiae mem, and ; invc?lication sIlol:1(j h:iyc hccl first inado j Congress abuse their power, tins abuse is m which tneir power was undefined In; th(j con ences of tj0 comsQ as weH not an act of the people-it is their own act such a case it was necessary 1o reflect deho-, ho or; ll cf lho po,vcr. : ualitv of for which thoy are personally responsible, crately on tne consequences of our conduct , - , foundation of our theorv of
The power that is now claimed, is rel.eyed ; fP-n, An inux)rfnnt i.i, flf tbi It had been said that the charge before die
from the check ot the co-ordinate branches j ,,rt ; 4'4: r! House comes within ihe provisions nf Uo
equalii, i? i-11 utii iiuiiiiiii&tiaiiuii i - ..;m;.ii T It uxor, tinr.rlr.rl i.ito in i Coustituf ion, protecting freedom of debate.
Vi ilil Ilia X JL',i i . uvuiuv vi i auii vv jh i -
to which the ordinary exercise of our func-
and delicate magnitude.
ject ot great
Aj r. Cuy iii his report disapproves of any
A A. reduction of the price ofthe public lands: He disapproves .of a cession to the respective states of the'l inds lvinsj within the limits ol't'ie states And he particularly disapproves ofthe yim ofthe Secretary of the
tions is suojeciea uy ue u,( . f a onaI contcst bctwcen two
cise the lowest attribute of legislation, on
individuals, to carry tne one before the cor-
before a tribunal wiio personal Jv espouse the
lhis is
.nuuie oi it-giMiuuii, , . r . , f . , .... . , ;f
the most trifling subject, so as to render it j ; igt Js victorious to uJe case
i l i' r"1 t T..t K :
oranencs 01 me vjournuie:n. uui ueic - ,.0011:tj,,i
cnects. it is huiejv uii tuu yiuuiuui uui r, it Kf r.-;,-;., . r 4i. ir.ie.
- -- iiii riiiii'- nil itiT. iiiiviif ifi- ill I-: ii:!!!
: nil uuu) j o ..." '
Treasury for tiie disposal ofthe public lands.
It had also been suggested t!rat the inch- j Tiro plan lecommended by Mr Clay is to vidual charged was anxious to answer to disposer fine public domain according to the the charge. Whether the person charged j present price per acre, and divide the pro
came before the House willingly or unwil-! ceeds among the states in tee ratio of their
lingly. he had the same objection against j repr.
oeiiu
we are sitting m judgment on tne chiiacter , laimcdas t oflllc pov,-cr oi-tllc House to and liberty oi tlie citizen, in a case m winch j hs delibcrationsi. 1Jut tllG true
wr fim nor3nnn v fnnromon umt n it htiv 1
own interest in the case that wc have grasp
bout hives
tio-ation into our ri'dit to do so. lie had vo
- - Ky
! jrround of privilege is not of members outol
re . .
but me
After the House has adjourned
i . r i- : : : ia a uuui
ea ai me pouei u.umuii u wmuu uivc.- , h.terruntion of debate. Will it
tOOil pt!
1 .nif,nrlw 1 lliqt tlil5 Ti- i- i 1 r rt o nvrt'.onts 1 1 r
ted agamst the resolution, oruenng tne ar-! mpmhGra afcr lIiev aro thron rjnoniI ,he
ed for a careful examination
He was anxious to know
-i rrti 'a a I a 1-
derived, inesuuaiion onnis nuumis, . - . in f10;r r,.
. i.. r. ,v.. ..-ii.. T) -ilJ, Tl.. ' utrtrniaii ... .
totally Oiiiereni nom uui oi me d.uim not intncW bv the
11 , .1 A
on, allowing to me seven wesi-
admittinff as forcing him to answer. He j ern states 10 pr cent, in addition to their would not consult the feelings ofthe a ecus- i slrrc according to their federal numbers.
ed in this cas e. He was unwilling to cocmtenance any precedent which would make members of Congress a privileged order in this country. In Lnglaint it is only the Lords
that are strictly a privileged order. Th
. It may er may not be the best dispo silica of ihe public lands, prueticable. 'Aery scheme in relation to an appropriation of our vast national demain must be attend" ed with great difficulty. It mav certainly
Housecf Commons; when one of their mem-! bo objected to Mr. Clay's scheme that it
hers was attacked bv the minions of Charles ! -amounts t a direct tax upon th? west and
upnp, the voor ofthe west tho
make tho
and Mr.
Criminal Law but protected themselves ! Clay's rcpo;t informs us that Oluo, icntucky
and Tt-nneFsee are tiie principal em'grat-
t
into tills riffht. i , v , . , l A ; u- I w:t cut off instead of interlrinfr vilh nionc.rs th iiiulvrmirrmts who
;A.nn.I T 1 1 M -1111 I hhllli II I I III I I I I I J .1 -
whence it were ! o indiVnnnr I questions of pnvdege, permitted trie ellenu-M;rst roads, ;:n l bndd the first bridges,
U.v miiit . j-, , - 1 1 I ,1 T i t , (, i i .1 . r
) ersto be oumsnea uv tue oramarv iouns o: reiC( m me Wiiuerness on tne liomier.
withdraw tne
r.,) pnunscl vere
-it x..... vnmi-kerl that the motion
o c. i-rl " i I r 1 1 11 1 111'
nd as tne accused a
holief that it would oc-
v O UiU vl -
anxious to proceed, he would withdraw the o)-,0n The SpeatvER .enquired of Oener"rTTnion whether he was prepared to pro-
llod within trlal-which he answered in
tlie a'irmative. The Igp-vKER ordered that tlie letter of Mr S- vnhekhy containing the charge be iVd, and then propounded the first inter'outcry in Ihe order ot proceedings, us fol
lows:
Do von son nt
liament. ihe origin oi that is hid ni mc , . r Thntm.a nro- for the luture by passing what was cal'edthe;
dark ages, and its powers are unlimited, be- , Qf q membcr ()f fhis bod is of Coventry net, from the name of the member ing Stntes. The burden oi creating tlm cause thev are undefined. Our Situation is j j t (ijn;tv of life and correct de- who was maimed. Hero we have no such , great fund lor d'Stnbution, thcreioro, will directly the reverse. Everyman has in his j in debate. Thcsi are' his most act, We have never said whether this ; pvinci pally, rfal hi on these Stztct. hands the instrument on winch the powers i i sye(h from insults abroad But ! charge constitutes any odier crime than the i We do not believe that a proper system of this House are based. They arc ex- "l"' yiolcnt tiraacs against private h'e at law. If crimes are not pointed rf donations to actual settlers would ope r-
pressiy liuiiti u.tuiii ut rhar-cte- which are indulged on this lloer, 13 " V1L,I , r, ' ".x Tnent. The power claimed by the House in Cll,u . ' . .K4m.r ck,,i,i k ovf.,n,i ted? h it a crime not to lilt one 3 hat to a , however it mijrht retard the sles of land jo-
1111 M. I l.UVfjl .IHUl I v-. " - ' ' I
I 1 ! In tiiis vcrv case,
the present case is found in the Constitution, or we do not possess it. The gentleman
from Pennsylvania, Mr. Coulter says this power is inherent in such an assembly that it is absolutely necessary to have it,
It was
1 f t-1 i 1 If 1 . 1 ' - .1 , ..nl.dMl
upon tne proposition to - " " ; " ' ; 1
haS W mat ieble prnk-! n. nlaivboviolatcd whlcl. never i far asCli',:,, is .concerned i, might be shown, hl 1 " ; ITe well acquainted existed? II th: House psS-fScs certa.n j would ir, a sene of 13 to 15 years enure U,
i ,niin,i tU.niJ.unknown immunities, wnere do tnf-y str-p. ! their benefit.
tlnt 11tU IIM"1I .1111 I11II.?IC,llIllt.l!.:fl'- '
wiui mat iiiuiuuui)u -i
Houston to bo hanged without trial, as to i Cbv in severe
or d'
mv
thai
you assaulted
ii .i.ca;.l Stnuberrv, as ho lias re pre-
!eied in the letter which hns been read, a copv of which has been delivered to you by the order of the House? To which Gen. Houston responded as Su ncc.!SCd denies that "he assult-
, d and beat the said Stannorry as he has relented in the letter v.ucn has been ierLvi , 4 f.At n-cat indignation
cn reading in t
and therelore wc nave it. u wds a . f , r:, thc ,ren.
doctrine to him, tnat a man had omy to . p!C(1 tcrms Gf abuse so libershow that he neeaed a thing, to enable nm "- ,1 to establish a perfect title to d. He had . his rc.
hcretoiore supposed that it a man neeuea a - Sr; man in carv thing to which he liad not an undisputed ! t n iVine'nt crisis in our national af-
t" 'fill. ll: wiiv. ,.- 4
on the ground ol ncce
th.e person to wnom
a mant attended,
conditions and limi
said that if one ot tne members 01 ine iiouso , , amcmber of this House, in
was murarcu eijuns raipht be tried before
he alad to learn the lounuation 01 mis , -, p rS Tf,nnoPP TTo i
1 Tfjvoi nor 01 in-1 ---"'- -.- 1 , , . tt .1,1 cAA cn. ( hocmicn. viuvtiuui vn. i rrri'ii'mU vr.to in
"ir IIP. WOU1U WV KWU U uiv vviu.. ... nvon- AmnnMll .111(1!" "'- rv-"" "
i i . v , -ts.; ,1-,.- 1 lTtr? 51 111 i;UlllUl ilV . i.j. .v. v. .... . , r.
.ot been subdued in view of the vast I charge ol Uen. Houston irom
the power ot
..-V11-M1 rricnnT! t I w r i 1 1 1 i i i . .
Have we not the same right to order (Jon. j Mr. Benton availed die report 01 ix
terms. He called the bill
be arrested without law? If the people of j which accomp'snicd the report, a bill "for the this country are to be governed not by know n ' depredation, tlie enslavement and impoverlaw but by any whim, caprice or excite- j ishment of tlie new States " mcnt into which we nuiy la?h ourselve. it He said "It was a most hideous and ini-
i e. i TC i..,.. : k;u !oftrrt thnl thr mnst
ii' j ; K i!i ( i ii i iv .. it 1 1 I 1 1' :i . il a in 1 v ' . . i i 1 1 1 1 i 1 1 .-i i;i 1 1 . a j v. i. .j.. . . .
i hn corviro or n:s eonnirv -' -.- , i - . . ... , -, .
. i . ' t u r ; 1 1 ii.;v7 - .j...- , . . i . i i i n l . i . i . i . . i I . . . . i c Ton
ssitv. but to appeal to ? . u -ih yAn our protection is necssaiy, 101 it nc maae i aeacuy nosi;n; io uiu nuw aunt.
t r Wrbtfii v he on.'jed tor " , 7, , t mid understood the people wi 1 hen know i or was destructive,- ana its means oi geuuiS
v fl I musket on Ins sncmuer. x-iuui m,111i , . ... ... .u. . : :i...ir .,,,,1
it noppcssrv. w i 11 ti i ...... 1 . 1 u- inn it is v f't'. ; i 11 n ll i t n km. s 1 hsm u iit.n. j inu
i -i-- i,i:. , ron , v.- hv h!? rnnniffs ana la on . 1 : 1 . t
tations. It has been ; UUUL ! "4 T'll rov .u n p.rlv roi i i?bment is inflicted. 11 rules mus? be estnl;- o-Tered a reward m money lor its
.1 i T rflSf O H' UllUiai - -IV t t . l . A. .T T r - ,.-1, r,.ccr.rl it
he vii to rorriitnio t:i ? i " i':!iii 1 t;i winn ui uiucc mn r"-
I 1.1... v. . . . .... . . - - . .
abominable. It
own pa?-
were to ian
... . . mi r . i r j
fmv:.r.U tho inf-m ifN (it I US ho: V ' ImT 1.1 t iC .i.A) mslllOIiSOl ?CrCS Ol UIHl
:re the guilty actor tlemanly deportment was still fit.zens toward, the members o tins boy, lr to the m f limbered He afterwards was chosen t them be promulgated Avh.e notn.ng , ,vmch the new ste the foundation of this j romemuertu. fT n ; js defined, nothing js violated, lie snould ; vule among themsc-h
pov
ntos contained, and to di-
;cs the 450 millions ct
favor of the dis- j dollars watch were to be obtained for those
jnunntcu u i, nVTimYn T)nvile2C3 of the members of :
. -UTI. norontn ciii " I o
.iv; tx-niumallntellisencer, re- every matter, uui .cu, r. thia bodv. He would warn gentlemen j
' . . - . 1 :...I,.rt.rl?11?il,llllJl"l.l-.MIllllTL7V. lilti-VlO
:inivi;i.-s wi mv.... , .
men:
his
coniine-
Titirks there
riiu Stanoerry
- i . . . i i ..... i
i k,.,. hoMi nnno on i priu"c ui i"'-- j - i ivrvi upon me r sruia ui m-n .
iteo .: .;b, for anv conduct whatever Do 1 c ,,i,:,.i, t?,ov , vm-;mnnrt;,ni
tt...,, l-'onrrm -IllUilvr " i- -!- ' . - . , t-i lrv.r :fi7Pn?. X 11" . i .t..... . ..... ......
1 lLOU, : ' . hv ! the oriviles ol this House extend to wan- j -th so much avidity, was I Clav to the senate
. - . r fT 1 I .11' .I v --- v-"- i i . 1 l- ui ' i i ! i I I I At.L.V j ,
,mpuL.u irrelevant slander; involving the i . The American ! re wrt is not idve:
miencem ;.;fin(1fUnnal feeling ol any body and every . Kfr,; thit members ! an outline is
niil Hie ll I i f i ! tt l TieODlvi Hi iii'- iw. " i" ' : aml .... i... ,.t, t- Iwidv ? If a member of this House becomes, t'; .thn-rd to insult who- rd Intelli.oer.cer. vh
10UVrnt ci Elated to c Tect j so lost to all sense of propriety and dignity - . t cy covj evidrntiv ;r ! ns to use his seat on this lloor ibr the mere er u l broucht,
mrlpr. LlWfl liiv. , . . . 1 l HUUbi; uiv-ui c..." . - . .
tl..i. . , . VprillUT IltS lH.-IUiiai J-LU111 I 1 J .....Tilnrr Irvi- Ml 1. t nnnn-T 1
I in 1I- LMll r- i . . . i.ia in t lPir mvil llu.HU Milllli avji i. nji ui'; tvi"
1
1 md-! It o.U, red a direct reward in money j to all who woi Id, in all time to come, vote against reducing the price of public
Pl'lll IC L WPS i lands, atjamsi ooiiutiuiia am t in
rertwnsn-debvMr.!ttlers, against uonamni io
ontheU.th. The whole , against coni. nu
. ;.. tt.o WnsMnnnm. da ms: lor all sucn were to no oeneimta
1 lil liiv 4... t '
nsu
Stanberry, in
name, a gross
elf lobe innocent
which throng licit; on, was
and
.iv.. - . ;.,,!iir.r..-
tanccs the accrseo Ii t an individual, is ant inquiry into h;s
'"r 1 . . r !.-. limner, i looc!i nt
. i - niu in iii iii; .a .j1 c . v. . .
immunity ot speech on
hat of a lawyer in a court
:s his argument is cor.-
red Sv tKo Pc-us- lined to the suhject heiore iuumii,u,r
r;dcul,ted .tiU iuruicr u. uwag r?al.haw interposes its protection against any ed- Theaccusedaamuatnd.n-
cu
. . r-i f I .11
ounv- . . r ,.. ,.,( -,n lino
;o-, whethrr the repu- - Tn i privilege? Sir, tiie
,n;A v,ns trulv set tortn m p-i - ' i . fl - is liko t
,,birh cnr.v.ry thus mad. , si a justice so long i
cneeche
1 . rril 1 , ..t
lication m newspapers, i iius uaniuuy only the right of slander, but of libel 1 As mntfer of curiosity, he would be glad to
line is published in the Nation- by saving even nc.e .u um u , ior .. u -Cer, vhich closes as follows: ! benefits, and exactmg $1 tor each cere, ral conclusion to which the corn-; It was the first tune he hao seen such a bill. !.,., JnrWiif.nt ! Itwas a monster, the s-ghtol which roused
. fe"-, 7 l .
icvcvnmcnt citiier lott.u
l:er to ced
within whicii
they lie, or to reduce their prices, i ne
ajrain advert to me mcrns oi --.,
the public lands to the State-
know
It 1 Ul tUl 1 " O I " . I 1 of some rrentlemen, learned in this j system for surveying and selling those lanos
matter cf vjrivilee, whether this protection liut they vemarK that
comprehended all publications waatever pe consiaerea wiitiuei
that it may very pioperly
the pioceeds ots.de s,
i i i . : : ll.. ,.iii nrr
a u n ca .mis jiui nauoi'. iiv i"u rest in pcr.ee in the presence of such a thing. He ld, thep fore departed from all the .iccste-nu-d modes cf acting in the Senate. He had attacked it at the first appearance. Ho took it at, 1he f.tst he p.' Xationcl JirptUlcan,