Indianapolis News, Indianapolis, Marion County, 3 May 1894 — Page 2

gg&xg:

a e»l*mitie» that com# apoa i.altcj Are*, flood*, sarth

»hich require irome* • He*M«o^iolaT«r

idioK aueh to be cold, and

pau*p«rum

wmm

*’• Pt^er On “The

r History w and

Diacassioa.

ir ;

■

Tutk" DiKlM«4 •f **•« *«▼* J. E. Catlicll—Per- ■»«»««» Orf»»ia*ti**_Preai*«at lturroafh*e A44ra*a —Tli* ReeepUeaa, Ete.

nouaced the cons

.

I*':' "

E&l

tun «VMtt£UKi> XKNia. The wbjeoMor the atteruooa wae ‘ < Th# Bubweryed Teath.’* «aa nrweated hy the Rer. J. Catheil, «»I Hwhmond. He «pok' diitiactioa between man eharitie* elevation oi the individual. Tie ■ah* merged tenth, he said, refers to all the helpless psopls, all tha wretohed p-sopls tn

tbs werid. ii

in this cttv. where so Serins prompts to despair. Ana these people are bone 01 our bone, and exactly ef ear Kind, and I do not know bat they shonla be Of oar decree. The things that relate to tee submerged tenth, the miserable

selves absolutely to tbs

a iSm

mjjs. atrelie/ of our fellow-

— r ' »ot want to preach, I do not want to talk shop, bat I want to say that we have a call more vociieroua than ever before to bo! oar fellow-men- 1 am afraid of institution;) charititti. I am afraid they build up * hairier between the best and the worst. The submerged tenth is on ens side ana we are on the other The oharity organizations should have the interest of every individual member in the work—not your money but yeuraelf; not your superfluity bat your own soul and il>e, and time an. energy. There is a small hospital in Rich' mona, and I have learned more of the gospel ' Jesus Christ in that hospital than 1 have ‘ in the books. It is not enough for

K about these things in our .luxurious remoteness from them,

saply throw out these matters suggestively >re you. Read when you go to your homes epistle of Taul to Philemon. He asks lemon to receive sa a brother Onesimus,

a thief and a stave. Read that

it. Receive this mar of religion, in the

tie man as s brother,

s of hu-

ysBMAKxirr orgaihzatxok. Dr. L. M. Underwood spoke on “Permanent Organization." His remarks were M {allows:

or fate has produced its unfavorable results, the fhudameatsl cause of poverty is laziness — deep-seated, inherent, overwhelming. Extremo poverty is in most cases voluntarily assumed, (ft) The step from beggary to brigandage is a simple and easy one. So soon as a man or woman loses sell-respect sufficiently to live voluntarily by the labor of other people, he naturally and readily loses moral distinctions in the methods of obtaining that living, (fl) Poverty is psr-

little dlitsreuce oetween the travsliag msndi-

PHHi^Brnnua^l

lead of continued in his condition. (6) muiation of men in migratory

tals only an aggravation ,of the ordinary Question. It is the lad Of the day to or-

ganite. Conventions, unions, organizations

are in the air. Even clubs have spirit; else, why are we here? It is

Us tramps ha

° r< S n ught the not re mark-

appeasing a more morbid reading 10 - they ksve bein encouraged ‘move on.” pot by the policemen, by blatant demngognes of Populist Ind have been sided and al

opu.

abetted

' persons who, for advertising purposes, have ■tribnted rations to them, or for fear ot injury to property ha latter type, and wo have no use for people who are sympathetic end pious “for revenue only.’’ TUB RBXKDIB8. But whet of tee remedies? I speak mainly Car towns of small or medium six#, for they Will cover the local problems ws sts forced to meet in our Btete Tbs Urge cities will n«turallir nrtatssi' eoma

i matter the powers of tha centra! organizai should be as potent as the power of a 1 of health iu stamping out or preventing ipread of other forms of contagion, lor premeditated poverty possesses some of ths \ phases of epidemic disease. The ideal type for S central bureau is one outeide tha jurisdiction If aither sociosiastical or secular politics, but i the e might be better than none at all.

•m

Will proba

attest. The common pi regarded as a harbor by

iii

dfedptine as follow*-, (a) A I

“0 takes a prominent part, (b) •lion, (c) A modicum of labor cover the necessities of food. The i, in roost cases, be required flrat,

w as nn equivalent, (d) hecesand shelter should he provided conditions only, (e) In case ot

or physical exhaustion medical at-

supphed. (f) The work supffe; if such a character as to

the establishment partially eelt-sup- . This will vary with tU locality. ■nlHhmMBBngagcd in volun-

cants—the natural

r conduenient ler reform or

axtlmctioB* In either case, a survival of the Attest. The common prison ought not to be

1 as a harbor by the buy. its for charity would tierent treatment- The i hand opportunities for

lain work for those of both sexes who are lysicaljy competent. It should provide

ry relief sod treatment for faoae who A bureau of industry should be a Hj > of the bureau of charity.

SBSK OUT THE WORIMV.

i these passive powers the bureau _ b* antireiy engsgsd in seokiug out I worthy poor who have not yet loet their , and who can b« encouraged, not f gifts of money and clothing, but by openlaveauasof usofulnass and opportunities lomuneiftive labor. At the same e faculties for bettering the social loh ought to bo provided. Rcading»can bo organized where healthful liter- . adapted to the oondltioas. can be obtained; methods of relaxation in the form of games, masic. convarestumal Iscturea, Ulustratecn, will readily recommend themstive*. and this phase of tea work nan wall servo as a means of

KINDERGARTEN WORK.

Lois G. H afford gave sa ontlino of

kindergarten work in i* »any branflkaa as it is carried on in this city, and of the g^ent benefit this work did to the par. uta, as well as to the children in its immediate care, kin. Halford showed that the kindergarten had greatly improved many neighborhoods in this city, sad in some had sflbcted almost a sompiate reformation ia tha way On the subject, “College SeUlements, T. O. Ailord, of Purdue University, took the place of Mrs. W. Bent Wilson, of Lafayette. He gave the history of the college settlement, that is, the taking of g house in

■ , college gradu-

out says Mommssa’s history tea masterful wu&SWiLsv&tfi aafflfcSSra this or tegt man's view of the events. But while there is tbi* di iterance u» view as to what history is. !wf,

is this nnity with hsis history ia with them sU is

arian atUropte to follow,

T 11 UMng to the rivulet, fre

the branch, ftom tha branch to the creek, then to the river, and. Anally, to the pi and or dinded iptotwo^great types—the artistic type

. TBB ARTISTIC TYPE.

Tbs artistic type extends ftom Herodotus, ia tea filth century before Christ, to Gibbon, in the last half of tee eighteenth century, A. p., a period of more than twemj -two hundred

years, T period ft< —someth

The sociological type comprieee the om Gibbon down to tee present time

ing near a century and a half.

the poor part of tie city by 11.. _ I atea who. there by example, showed the

surroanding coimuunity had to live, irked that in treating of tha eahma

: Kdffl leal or pail

“** B fiSeta ifivol

such portraits

engaged him. as would charm r and warm the emotions of rs and reader*. He was not critn itaking as to the exact hiatorical olved, but, like his brethren whose

session of the Union of

llnhs yesterday the president ante* commitlea to consider tha

propriety of dividing tee Bute into sections

for oooTeoiencfi ioteture programs lows: lira. Bradbury, Kichmo Woollen, Indianapolis; Mrs. Bmart, •Me; Mr, Butter. Brookvills; Mr. Bloomintftou: Mrs. Manteeld, |<re. Dooley, Mra. Cohen, Mrs. Mrs. Moons and Mra. Mendenhall

jr uavpvja * to, vs

infiaenee. Tbs Oirsetioa a shsrity may take : of depends on the astute andeondmon of tUono t ;e * n eur p a

hnlp fud An tli a AharActiir of wam cnovi

rnagmssss

>* subordinate and supi orTginsi and directive th* lesson, too often

“t:,.

raoe first humanrd Christianized, and that

g the order, constantly

: is simpler, but became ISA V*S *f» »**vs*«w m szxgsi co-oparatlop ol

who need help and on ths. fbsracter of the person who gives it. The spurif of an and infiaenee ot Calvin Fletcher, James M. Bay, James Blake and others placed a stamp Indianapolis, which to-day is the best

mm country bo-

on Indianapolis, which today ia governed municipality ia this e<

cause of it* fovmfiffA

be discussion. H tion teat frlopdi;

that women

Mr. CsiheH clased th' made the recommemlat

clubs bo organized and that women ope their houses snd work to help their fellows

and build a fire of friendliness.

Meredith Nioholson read, by request, a number ef his own peems. He chose “Personal 8arvie•, ,, "Verses on the Indiana Soldiers' Monument," “Watehingthe World

have never if weU told,

tical reflection

l. A good story, _ ....

was en oyed for Its own sake, and was noqe tha less thought of teat it mingled Action with fact. He was a portrait painter on paper aa truly as Polyalitus was an canvas, and he used hit imagination and stylus to present ideal pictures as ireely as Phidias used bis imagination and

•aktlwrL.^^ -

Go By" “Eseheat,' 1 "Jikyme of Little Girls" and “Shadow Lines.” This contribution te the program of tho afternoon was received with tnsuy egpresaioasof pleasure.

ON QRANP OPERA.

A paper by Mrs. William U Elder, on “The Growth «l Granfl Opera,” was then read. It was illustrated by the voiee, violin, 'cello and piano. The earliest forms of opera were described and their limitations pointed onk The old orchestras wore so lacking in initrumenta of different

ireely aa Phidias used bis imagination and mallet to carve ideal ‘orras. It is meant to say that this was his ideal. He was not the maq te have spared his pains if he had thought it best to search every coign o* vantage for historic tecta. But in his portraiture he did not desire to present everv eye-lash and wart upon the see of society, but only such salient featurpa aa would give s pleasing and charm-

m&m William Tell and John Smith, boots, to the Witness-stand to pass shgrp jss-cxuinination. Then she was rather fond moratizing; now she is disposed to conflne melt mete closely to the feete, and do is possible to aiscover the great forces b move nndor society and hhid it late aa organic union. The scieaee of historical criticism has arisen, whose tendency is to tear away all shreds oi likelihood, au shreds of poBs.bihty. irora the choicest, ths E’saf ssrjFasssrs a»«?s foundation by King Allied, since it has been shown that there Is not s shadow of likelihood that King Alfred had anything to do aawXJef.SVht.r ISff. ,‘KXi. £ terest in Pocahontas has moulted most ef its

clous or unintentionally lalse? Or, to -stats the question in general form: What is the modern critical school, with Its methods for

laying

they with

fields of dat

may be most is its methods for inva

*°han

ion

died

in-

eluding the discovery of material criticism and proof of genuineness; and finally its

acitriy ‘°| nvestiRsti naterisl c: mra va 1 ,

method* for determining how nearly s record, if genuine, really refleet# the file scene of that which it attempts to reflect. 1 say how nearly is this scarab after historic truth arriving at

the coveted goal?

r be admitted outright teat these new

muse, with all

never can

an*

be

features aa would give a pleas ing picture, and oue that

moralised about.

be much

mon

THB QBKBK MODEL. As has been intimated, the Greeks were the inventors, and perhaps the unsurpassed exemplars of the artistic type of historical composition. Tbs model set by the Greeks In this field was much more worthily followed by the

•Livy, sa

ranked high for true of language, and The student of his-

111 be early struck with the

m literature upon the conblic freedom which characterizes

ffft»?«siSj; Sg«i r ^ woghtines* ot judgment,

torical literature will 5Xi‘Tp“? s, ’-“ c

the time. T1

he great eohool of buoyant, active,

JK'--

WEST BOOM WHBBB THE HUGS A HE.

opera in France owes its establishment largely to the effort* ofLouisX. I. V. Gluok, Mozart, Meyerbeer,Thomas, Bisetand other composers of opera were spoken of. The speaker thought th* objection of lack of melody in Wagner’s innate unfounded. The illustrations were furnished by |(ra. Lottio Adam Raschig, Mr, John ChiyeU, MrAdolph BcUellschmiat sad lira- Elder herself, who played the idgno.

PlfiCteteSUM OF HIMTOBT. Prof. Kemp’s Paper on the Kfterature of Blstery—Views of Others. Tho last days of tee session of the fifth annual ceuveation of the Indiana Union of Literary Globe began at 9 a. m. to-day with the readin* of the minute* of yesterday. The platform upon whioh the preaiding officer and the secretary sit wo* rearranged so that the Hont of the ito$« extended fgr into tea center of tel foow, whUa tea sa«U ot the audience van arranged i« wider semi-circles. Mra Watsog Webb Woollen moved that the secretary express to the Watte*« Association of Writers the grateful acknowledgment of the union of tho invitation to its meg) hers to attend the annual meeting ot the writers at Warsaw;, and that tee president appoint « delegate te represent this union at that meeting. Tha motian was carried unanimously. Mrs. Bradbury, of th* nommitteo on division of the Stele into districts, for program purposes, asked further time. On mopoa of Mrs. Gregory, th* committee we* mtiuued until next year. Mis* Minetta Taylor moved a resolution of thank* to tee press for full and careful reports of ths meetings. Tho motion wi referred to tho committee oa resolutions. PR0KB8S0R KBMP’a PAPER. Prof. El wood E«wp, Terra Haute, rwd an essay on tea “Literature ol History." Thu was in suhstanoe as follows: Thera u no small div*z*m fg tea meau&ug says, in the _ last pari of the discus-

name, but is nothing foes teau tee sum total

. ^ degree in the robustness national It s. snd fructified in ths histories ol

furection

war, te* gra.id

democracy under Elaine lisroel and the energetic actura Oi the flret States General of Prauce produced Froissart. The fiiteenth Ceutury struggle between feudivlism and monarchy produced a competent but rustic Tacitus in De Coniines. Ia the stirring times of the sixteenth century historians abound- Italians, Frenchmen. Dutchmen—

vila, De Thau, Grotms—to name le chief. But during the strong —chical reaction ot the seven

hut a lewqr the c papal apd monur teenth and greste

greater part of the eighteenth cen-

tury, there is not one continental historian whose name is now remembered or whose works are at present read. This barrenness o. hiatorical writing is the more remarkable

wing. A OHAHOn CAME. Bat with tee close of the eighteenth century a change was a* hand- As bos been aaid, up Vo that time tee historian was engaged largely iu portrait painting and in moralizing. Moreover, almost ail of the ancient historians, snd a great many of those of the middle age. had confined themsefves to writing history of Tke decadence of history

disciples of this stern-grown must

their refined methods of procedure,

arrive at one fragment of knowledge with i solute certainty—the certainty which is to ;ittr,bated to that which has tee very highest w5rS. M KjE some warning about tbe certainties of mathematical knowledge, putting it, I believe, tbat there might be a world in which two and two should make five. I don’t know how this is. hut I have-thought that mathematicians taught that the troths o: geometry would he unshaken and tbe same in boundless scace, if this unlverso were wiped oat ql existence.

TRUTHS or HISTORY. , ;

But the truths of history are not only below those of the mathematician in certainty; they are below the troths which the natural philosopher ia able to arrive at. One can be much more certain that tbe son rose a million years ego and will rise a million years hence than he could of any historic event eo remote io the past or so distant in the ioture. As to the rising of the sun, either in the past or the future, there is but one thing that makes it uncertain—that the existing state of things now was or will be different from what they

are at present.

As to the historic events of a million years on either side of u*. they have been, or will be, governed by tbe human will—whose action, we will allow, is somewhat less certain

than the action of the sun.

And then, there is this farther difference which makes the naturalist more sure of his knowledge. The sun, and the rock, and the plant go through with acts, as it may be popularly expressed, but they never try to gloss aver, and cover up, and conceal what they have done. Not so with acts of men. The will of man fixes what shall be believed to be what man bo* done in the past. He may state this truthfully or untruthfully. The will ol man will determine bis acta in th#

future^

For "example, take records o the past : of as to the acts

few examples of the What can we be certain

acts and motives

»e i

of

Hannibal,

with ail their attendant ciroumBtoncfs?

is, i the

so tar as known

n, I believe, not a syllable o

record of bis doings which comes down to

us >rom him.

Hannibal, in so

s ail history mqst knov

does know bin

os it

ax m si si a wax, rxa ox# ***»

through his enemies—the Remans. Take state records o! Europe in the times w mona:chy was struggling with freedom in its earlier efforts, it fs the purpose of these records, perhaps, quite as frequently to conceal the truth as to reveal it. Every single irngroent ’of evidence was destroyed by Dudley and Elizabeth, or by somebody eiee tor them, which would throw aray of light upon the cause of the death of poor Amy Ronaart,whose mangled body was foundat the bottom ofthe stairsHow shall we ever k now the truth of what the Star chamber did and how it did it> It kept

proceeding#. Or, tak< f jury proceeding in

Star chamber did and how it did it? It kept no record of its proceeding#. Or, take the whale history ol jury proceeding in England up to the time ot the Revolution. There can not b« anything api roacbing a nigh degree ot certainly that any particular verdict rendered by ■* jury tor centuries bet< re the revaiutiou wak in accordance with the evidence. Jurymen were ret eatedly imprisoned and fined for not render-, ing deebions in accordance with the will of the Court. There are three aillerent report in part variant and contradictory, of Mirt

beau's , , whftbad sent to derattn ^ , Constituent Assembly. Yet these reports are from ear-witneases. Or a single instance from our own country. * * • HISS RUNCIE’8 VIhWS. The discussion of the essay was opened by Miss Annie M. Runcie, of Evansville. She

said:

I must begin this discussion with a protest

distinctions seem to me arbitrary and misleading. In my conception of it, artistic history did not end with the Mriod preceding Gibbon, but has continued to the presenttime, oil history worthy ot the name being artistic. Modern history ia but the artistic, enriched by tbe sociological. If artistic history be the portraiture o heroes, through the medium of the imagination, the world’s history is but the history of its heroes. Carlylt soys that genuine history ia aq epoch Oi heroism. Great revolutions have bsen but the expansion ot a great individual sentiment which, developing into a torrent of human leeling, bursts the old dykes and hurls the current of things into a new channel. Taine says the histonr of Puritanism is the history oi a Puritan—Thomas Ci omwell, as painted by Carlyle, whom he likens to Rembrandt. It is only as pictures thrown upon the canvas of time

figures of history live and breathe, leaving after them through the ages a great procession of those to whom they have been as an inspiration. A William of Orange, as depicted by Prescott and Motley, introducing to the

ot liberty and religious in a sense, of what the

to despise almost everything^ teat had gone archy of the present time. But a leeling of dissatisfaction and disenchantment with the present gradually set ia. Knowledge grew with unprecedented rapidity —Um enlargement oi the clvUUed world had bean taUowed by greatly increased practice of affaire; political sentiment was substituted for tee santiment of ehivolry. Adam ffmith, Us the“ Wealth of Nations.” soberly scrutinized

swsr

£„

ibutiun

But

vast regions of darkness, and some ways more powerful than

• of rill

Britannic*, “ureana the prose narrative of &!£e e dehnltfom? briefly • C * ctlow3r k 1 ™ 1. "History u a narrativo, oral w written, of past events." 2. “History is tee osoerded events ot tea Mat," *3. “History is recorded or aooompUahsd fact; also, th# aggregate of tea ayanto. roperiod of^®° d w 10 m * r % ca*ltl*'S visw. Carlyia aeoms to bnv# regarded History »• th* biography oi great man. “History,” says Galdwin Smite, "is a series oi struggles to elevate tea oharseter of humanity In all its

are, in tne c*,*o of inaivtauars.*' Freeman says: “If I were coiled on to define history I should bo inoUned to any that history is the science of man in his character ass po-

But perhaps this vonerai d#»# -■

Revolution. A new era was at hand. The scales which had hitherto dimmed and narrowed the vision, began to drop irom the cyee. The roinantio movement which I have hinted at sent the historian back to the ages oi antiquity to study the men snd women, not as Elirin inarb es, but os men and women, such as, “if yon prick them they would Weed.” nB-STCDT OF THB HISTORY. From reviewing afresh the heroie sue of fiqrsm find Rome, the heroic age of Christianity w«| restudiad ftom points of view which th* moral prejudice and want of knowledge of the antecedent centuries had made impossible, and then tee middle age, pivoted on the napscy, hitherto the great stumbling block; regarded by the Catholie as a divine institution; regarded by tee Protestant as the very embodiment of anti-Christ; regarded by the skeptic as pure superstition-this field was entered by sober-minded, relatively unpre.udioed »ehol*re like Gibbon and Bailees, and re-interpreted, not as a great baibar.c wedge driven tn between two civilizations but os a park and a mast important part, of heterogeneous mass called humanity. Thro, Christian church and

others profited

by modern historical re#earcn; eo many errors about them both have been unlearned; so truths new dreamed o. be.or^ it tne siraaie Age ana the early Christian chnrch received and profited by the illumination of the new lamp of history as have none other. Hot hut that the modem axe has profited, V. history has been rea resh since ISIS, but in

not been ^ aueh

aheo to’overcome as there had been in the

ago* immediately preceding it. SURPASSES ALL OTHER AQB9.

But in one particular the modern age surpaseet not only any other, but all other agesthe mighty fountains of historical lore, which were all bat looked up before the beginning of the present century, have thawed out and ftom Venice, tee Vatican, Spain, En•rein snd has come to her youth again , but different ftom tke youth of yore. Then ft he was an innocent git;, easter flattered, and

modsrn history there has not sM’SSX'it&na

A Willi

N e thS‘..‘» p .V„o; ■■■ tolerance, the creator, in a souse, of whs great moss of men have dene or accomplished. The record of the world is but the record of its heroes. The sociological but adds the accessories to the picture- It is through the imagination that the picture Hsel mu*; he presto ted to us; the details, tbe sociological pan, fill in, complete the picture, verify its correctness, give it realism. Fantasy is thine eye, it pas been said, with its calpr-givipg retina. The understanding is thy window, but fantasy is the organ of the soul. For a correct analysis or a revolution requires the divination oi an artist. There is no way of acquainting ourveivea with the events oi other days than to see the men of other days. As all great historical artists have done, resuscitate the soul before our eyes, and all the minutia ot the sociologist can be added to it. This is the first step in history—the step that was taken at the beginning of the last century.

TRUTH OK HISTORY.

Mrs, Clsybaugh, who followed, said the truth of history bas been a matter largely touched upon iu the paper and in the discussion. She spoke of the labor it took to write a history, the records to be searched, the places to be visited and ail things that must be brought to hear upon the facta What kind of a men is able to do these things? Not a poor man dependent upon his daily exertions for his bread and kutter, but a man of leisure of wealth, opportunity and intellectual ambition. Drudgery is always au essential of greatness. It takes a litetime to lean '

airasa* srsug?

pro vent tee making of flawless heroes. Kfmfisd’.Uted^hBt might* be 1 JSSd^i Up-to-date history. Ho raid thare wore one or two points which he would like to press hums, os this was a company without a creed, a dogma or a doctrine. Much of history is false. The cause that has led to ths rewriting of history >», first, tho Democratic movement; second, the growth of astural aeienee. The methods of the biologist have been turned oa the held ot history. While history is uncertain os to detail it ia extremely certain as to law. History proceeds according to ths law of cause sod effect Nothing impossible over happened. Civilization develops along the line of uniform progress. Like bees swarming about a hive,

each beo has it* inde pendent ■ ment ytt all move

sni and Miss Dugdale. Than was matin by Mata's ereheetre. Tbe boas* woo olaborstely decorated With palms and flags. AT PLYMOUTH CHURCH.

President Burrovg ,*, of Wnbniih, Speaks •f “Fri*na»i»ip in Letters.** Dr. Georg* 9. Burroughs, president of Wabash College, talked on “Friendship in Letters” last evening, at Plymouth church, to a large agiliepee, con)posed for the most part of the ladies io attendance upon the convention of the literary clubs. A brief musical performance preceded the talk of

President Burroughs.

He said it was the soul that gave birth to both letters and to friendsqip, and the move- j q n gUries and forces that made for one

together a j w f or the other, and that three two

ia a general direction. should be found in company. He said:

« mare lies gome iriendships are mode by oouti

greatness.

plod. The beautiful

litetl

things

learn to literature

are the result of years snd years of drudg# ery. How many of us would be willing to go through the task of Prescott, spending years snd years upon it in juilte of his blindness, because he liked it? Such men are true historians. Many histories lie anon shelves dusty and unnoticed. The principal thing necessary to the writing of history i* descriptive imagination which secs men os they lived and re m ' Aj ll

_ places as the*

Such historians «re few. Truth very evasive something. We

wo have it often when

it not. Sir Waiter Kqleigl in prison writing his history saw

v. —a. a _ . * . «

were, is a think have

whikiVPVMH through his grated

ef what we do, the human race forward ip one grand consolidated phalanx. This ia what tbe uew history says. It puts constantly less emphasis upon the particular fact, and mors upon the general law. Old creeds and dogmas are melting away. The great central truths of religion and progress, of the Buddhist, the Christian, the Jew, receive more sympathetic accept-

ance before the world. ONR KEY TO HISTORY.

Miss Minetta Taylor and Mrs. Virginia C. Meredith spoke briefly, and were followed

by Jacob P. Dunn, iie said:

I am not deeply instructed in the philosophy ot history. I dd not know much diusrencs between the artistic and psychological, tbs objective and subjective. I have learned that the publishing ot history is somewhat dejective. To me thera la but one key to history. Human nature at all times is the same. Hatred, love, philanthropy, ambition have moved men snd nations in all ages. I suspect most ot you accept that a* a platitude. X did not bellev* it myself until I went out among the MormonoAfter I had been there a few days t went to call upon Angns Cannon, a brother of the Utah Delegate in Congress. I said to him that it bad occurred to me that his people really believed their religion. After m-avlncine him that I was not s Government spy, he explained the theory ot the Mormon religion. He talked to me ol his belisi as a Methodist could talk of his. I left him, feeling sad that I was not a better man. He was a terward tried for polygamy. The judge raid that Cannon was a good man, and teia him if he would promise to abandon tho doctrine of polygamy he could pardon him. That man turned upon tho judge with a feeling of pity, and said: “l am not in th* habit of making promises to children.” And he walked into the nenitentiary. He was honest in his belie ; and unless the historian believes In the honesty of belief he can not write tho history of Mormonism. The two works that will live are the Bible and Shakespeare^ You eau not find a principle of human nature In Shakespeare that you will not find in the Bible. Ninety-nine per cent, of the histories that are ot any use to us have been made within the last century. The history you ought to know is the history or your own times or the times nearest to your own time. I have left here this morning a monograph on the township library. I hone this nnion will take an interest in the subiect. I wish you would do some original work in Indiana history in the county, township or town in which you live. Find out the history of your township library, of the success it became, the reason it Jailed and what became ol it. Find out what is the prospect oi replacing it or

having something in its place.

Professor Kemp closed the discussion by thanking those who had taken part in it. This was followed by “a musical hour,” by the Matiuee Musicale, of Indianapolis. LETTER FROM MAURICE THOMPSON. The following communication was read: Sukewood Pr.ACB, Crewi'ordsvilJe. Ind. Dear Mrs- WooHen—A short absence prevented an earlier acknowledgment o: your kind invitation: snd my wile now joins me in a pang of regret at being unable to accept. We assure you that it would be a great pleasure to attend the meetings and tne receptions. I am proud of Indiana’s organized students of

literature.

In these clubs arc- nurtured tha sweet bulbs

of richest future culture.

I beg to send fraternal greetings to the assembled representatives ot intellectual progress in our State. I am just sending regrets to the American Authors’ Guild, which meets at

folaoh Msss-, in a few da vice-nr evident, I can not

In literaturi

A committei ot tfie boird of directors of Butler University appointed to consider the affairs of the Bible college, of which Prof. H, C. Garvin is the head, met last night at the home of Dr. P. H. Jameson. The basis for the inquiry was the charge that the Professor was teaching doctrines 55, aaayJS szzxss'

areata, | m it tee was appointed two meetings of

& to saSki? 4 aga,F „

contract. Letters

SAY NO ACTION IS REQUIRED

CONCLUSION OF THF COLL RGB BO AMD ON THB GARVIN CAKE.

Corpoapondenoo Showing That iff. Garvin's Pc alt I on* Have Not Boon Correctly Meted—He Boldly Kxm preosoH Uiw Views-Heresy Cnso.

read atrise ftom

fool But

low a brawl in the

street near by. On inquiring about it he found that he hod been entirely mistaken ia his ideas concerning it it is raid he threw his manuscript into the flames, saying: “If I can truth concerning what took place centuries ago?" ft t» only within tbe last 1^ that men have given themselves to writing the truth of men and evt-nta. The first of these historians was Gibbon, but he has taken awsy from the perfection of hit work by bis skepticism. He gives historical truth, but there IS always the insinuation that there is no spiritnol truth. J-. absence of newspaper correspond-

ent*.

ye. Although I am

leave an inexorable task In literature, to which, for a while, I am

mortgaged.

Sincerely hoping the union will have a successful meeting, I am, vesy truly, yours. Maurice Thompson.

May 2.1894.

Meredith Nicholson, of Indianapolis, was named by the president as the delegate from the Indiana Union of Literary Clubs to the meeting of the Western Association

of Writer*.

A motion was made and carried that the books which formed the exhibit of the union at Chicago, be presented to the In-

diana State library. OFFICERS ELECTED.

Tbe last business of the morning was the election of officers. The candidates for president were Mrs. Virginia C. Meredith, of Cambridge City, and Mrs. Watson Webb Woollen, of Indianapolis. The contest between these two was close, the former receiving a majority of four rotes. The

officers elected are as follows:

President—Viiginia C. Meredith, Cambridge

Vmc-President—J. E. Iliff, Richmond.

Secretary and Treasurer—W. A. Branyan,

Huntington.

Chairman of Program Committee — Miss

Katharine Merrill. Indionanous.

Members of Program Committee-M. W. Sampson. Bloomington; N. A. Hyde. Indianapolis: Mrs. A. B. Mil.ord, Orawiordsvilie; Miss

A. D. Guild, Ft. Wayne.

RECKPTIUNS THIN AFTEKNOON. The Woman’s Club nr the Propylaeum—

At the Columbia Club.

Pansies—purple, yellow and white—in profusion adorned the parlors of the Propylaeum this afternoon, where, from 2 o'clock until 4, the Woman’s Club received in honor of the convention of Indiana clubs The pan-sy is the club flower, and the sentence from Hamlet, “There is pansies, that’s for thoughts,” the‘elnb motto. Several balls of the rich-hued flowers were swung from tbe chandeliers by ropes of smiiax, and vases of them were on the tables. Upon the wall were the initials I. W. C. inpansies and a tew pansies were given to eaeu guest as a favor. The invitation extended wus to all officers, delegates, visiting guests and members of local clubs in the union. It was the largest reception given during the couventiun, except the general oue of Tuesday nixitf. The brightness of the afternoon made the wearing of new spring gowns possible, and many of these were to be seen. in tbe west parlor the reception proper was held. The wall hangings, which were so effective on Tuesday night, were not taken down. Mrs. John A. iloiman, president of the club; Mrs. Victor K. ilendriokg, chairman of tee executive committee, and Mrs. Dryer, president of the union, formed the receiving party. The committee on arrangements consisted of Mrs. Chapin C. Foster, ehairmun; Mrs. F. W. Chislett and Mrs. Harry Milligan. Mrs. Bewail was chairman of the committee on introductions and Mrs. A. M. Rooertson of the committee on decorations. The club members were divided into sections, so that each chairman bad a sufficient number of assistants. In tbe east parlor the daintiest of refreshments were served. Mrs. Morris Boss was chairman of the committee on entertainment. Silver and cut glass were used entirely iu tee table service. Mrs. George Tanner presided at the north table. The Woman’s Club is known so widely over the State bit for visitors this reception bad an unsuai interest The grace and beauty of etail in all its arrangements, and the hositality extended by tee ladies who voiced »ne club’s welcome, made it on occasion to be remembered with pleasure. KATHARINE MERRILL AND CENTURY. bVAm tho l^rArvwlaxxsxui manror xar/vnt #-Jis-re Merrill and Centery Clubs held a reception from 3 until 5. The handsome rooms were filled with guests during these hoars. AU delegates and the officers of local clubs were invited, as well as the members of the Columbia Club. Mrs. Henry Coburn, president ofthe Katharine Merrill; MUs Merrill, V * * ’ '' ‘ ‘ ' *

i

souis'poesessed o common higher int letters in tee nobler sense. >'ou re tracted, you read charmed; you rise the reading elevated, inspired. You the uplift of friend*tup in ietterethe pen is not n. cogsary te this iriendship, true though it be teat pen and lip are in letters equally ready servaats of the soul. The spoken word may weU take the place ol the written; oftener it does. Indeed, It is because when tee utterance is by tee pea, tee pen is keyed to the voice’s pitch, that we find tee man of letters speaking to aa and not the scribe writing in Our behalf. Painstaking though he be. yet withal he is uninteresting, unvital, soulless. The soul necessitates friendship, and the soul necessitates letters, whether

uttered by pen or speech. SOOTT AND ABBOTBPOBD.

It was the soul of Scott teat made Abbotsford synonymous throughout tee literary world ofthe second decade of th* century, not only with princely hospitality but more essentially with internal spirit. We see tbat the leveling, uaitying influence ot literary friendship gives piny to criticism in its nobier sense. “There is much criticism-" rays Emerson, “not on deep grounds. God and nature are altogether sincere, and art—even the art ot ( iiic sm—should be sincere. Trn* art is sincere. True letters are. True friendship is. Thoreau was more than quaint. Aa interrogator of every cnetom—unmarried, a lone-liver, a non-church-goer, a non-voter, refusing to pay his tax, eating no flesh and drafting no wine —he was, as Emerson called him, 'the bachelor ot thought and nature.' We should call him the veriest crank. Yet see with what even-handed justice bis truth is measured snd his inward beauty first scanned and then set forth. Art and nature lie close together. Young was right. ‘The course of nature is the art of God,’and the art of man in letters is, therefore, even in closest sympathy with nature’s course He who Is permitted to give expression to tee spirit ot truth and beauty ‘in the greatest of the fine arts,’ literature, is, without exception, he who has first been permitted to discern and interpret these spirits m tee

natural world- How closely is

preachers have passed resolutions, asking Professor Garvin to resign. Three resolutions have hone to te* Professor, and not to the directors. Tbe committee last night heard all sides of the controversy. Copies of tho following correspondence, which will be published tbit week in the church paper mentioned, were submitted. vaorBsson uarviv’s hrrrsy. Prof. H. C. Garvin; Tbe Indianapolie papers of recent date contain the following resolution reported te have been unanimously passed by th* Crawford*ville Missionary Convention: “It is the judgment of the oonv«Btion that the churches of this district should reject all teachers who teach any or all of the toUowiag

doctrines:

“)• Repentance before £*ite in the salvation 0f “2. Il Bap l tism ot tea Holy Ghost and fir* ae

taking place now.

“A Judaism os being th*religion of humanity. and Christianity as only a new spirit put

into it

“4. And that the death of Christ bad no more to do with the salvation of men than that of any other good man. « ,} S. And teat the gospel of Christ is only a power among other powers in the salvation of m ^alving the question of the right of that convention to define the limits Ot Ohristisn isith, and understanding the resolution to r«ler to you p-imsriiy. and to your viaws, I write to >uu uir * l' the foregoing ip * correct

itlofi of your views, «

four and flv*. A

; is * correct sspecially tee in early reply

■ non or same in Chriswill greatly oblige your* ■ 19 j/H. Garrison.

representation of your views, ea

items numbered four snd fiva AU early reply withjs view to publication of same in Chris-

iw closely is th* soul of ging moods, joined to the -e, of clouds, of sunlight.

man, in all its chan^ mood oi atmosphere, Of clouds, of sunlight. It has been remarked that in the Canterbury Tales our English letters ‘set out, not ftom sn Alexandrian library, but from a goodly company ol sundry folk.’ Equally pertinent is it to remark that these ‘suqdiy oik,’ not only ot Chaucer, but of all English letters since, have moved aioag th# roadway ot life with nature’s lovelinres encircling them. Each could truly say, with Shakespeare: ‘In Nature’s infinite book of secrecy a little can 1

THB LAWS OP FRIENDSHIP.

The law of racr.fice. which is te# law of friendship, the law of'prodigal giving forth of the best, regardless of utility, of loss or gain, which is the secret of friendship in letters, is, after all, the law, the infinite mystery of nature’* life. To come under Us Impressive, allpowertul influence is to be fitted to fill one’s part ip the divine mission of letters to the heart of man. Just here, then, presses upon our notice the sad misuse, may well nigh bo said, of literary friendship. And yet this is a mistaken statement. Better were It to speak of misapprehended—yes, better stiU, or unattaiued—friendship in letters- One may love the beauty of this person, tjie good humor of that, the liberality of a third. But the friendship that possesses the whole souk and there rules and sways with absolute sovereignity, can admit oi no riyai. There may be neodships among men ot letters, but it mav not De that literary friendship of which we have been thinking. In this the moral element is sfrong; the element bf selt-giving and wide sympathy is at its core. Of it Chesterfield speaks when he says, “Real friendship is s slow grower, and never thrives unless ingrafted upon a stock of known and reciprocal merit.’' Byron and Shelly were friends, but in their cose can not be found the true, tee developed friendship of letters. While we culture true iriendship, w# culture true

ure bote

letters. We culture both wh-le w# love truth and beauty—while we gather together and ha monize all interests around our literary hearthstones, and. in the wSrmtb of common sympathies witJh better, nobler things, flit cuss them, each and all; while we foster the power to criticise in the atmosphere of appreciation; while we tbq* cherish the opportunity both of helpfulness and also of growth; while we

hlcb

mars all success in letters. Did Not Know Riley. This story is vouched for by a city official who was present at the conversation. Mrs. Jones and Mrs. Smith (which are not their names') are delegates to tbe convention of dubs. They met lost night. “I suppose you have seen Riley?" said Mra. Jones.

Who

“No-o-o-o, I don’t know as I have,

is he?”

“Why, James ^ Whitcomb Hiley. the

remember

Does he—ali-

live iu Indianapolis?" “He doe*. You don’t me*n to say that yon never heard ol Kiley?" “I never did. I read all the magazines, too. He can net be so very wrtl known, or I would have heard of him."

Hoosier poet, you know him?" “Riley—Kiley; no, I can not that I ever heard of him.

WEST 1NDIANAFOLIS VOTE.

Official Itotunm Show Vote Tver Cant In the

the I.tu’freat

Suburb.

Jesus died to appease even teat He died to

i justice, ae this expression Is od. He satisfied divine justice

tian Evangelist,

fraternal iy,

fit. Louis. April 34.

REPLY PROM PBOPRSBOR OARVIH.

J. H. Garrison:

As to No. 31 hold with A. Campbell, Christian System, p. MS. “Immersion not a mere bodily act,” This I always read to my clasaea as expressing my views. No. & I can not imagine what led them to make this charge. It is entirely taire. No. 4. This is lalse, yet I can see some little reason for the mistake. I can not here explain to you my view ol the atonemeut, which is peculiar. I deny that I the wrath o‘ God,

ratisfy divine commonly usi

throughout His liie in all He did and suffered. He was made per.ect os Savior, through suffering, so that He ■ le able to save all teat come to Him. No man is saved except by coming into Him—becoming a member of His body. Jesus is tee only Savior, and He became such through Hu Hie, suff ering, temptations, death snd resurrection. But He did not payoff a book account that was aiainst us. I make these statements not so much to explain my view as to show you how this charge, which ia utterly lalse, might arise in the mind* of dnthinking people. No. 6. It is hardly necessary to soy teat this is lalso, after what I have said above. I have certainly never intontionallv i aid a word that would justify such a report. Fraternally,

H. C. Gakvw.

. BDITOR GARRISON'S COMMBNT.

The resolution then,so faros It was intended to apply to Professor Garvin, does him very serious injustice. It is unfortunate that it should have been entertained, lor a moment, in a missionary convention, or, indeed, in any other convention. Professor Garvin’s

“heresy,” then, dwindles down to this:

L He believes teat the term faith is pot applied to the apprehension and reception of the gospel whioh precedes repentance, but tbat it is limited to that personal trust in Christ, which succeeds repentance. But thie is a difference, not m things, but in'th# names

of things.

S. He believes, with Alexander Campbell, that immersion is “not a mere botiily ” but is “sn set ot the whole man, body and spirit”; teat te* “soul of the Intel! subject is as fully iuraierscd into th* Jesue, as his oody is immersed in th# w that “his soul rises with tee Lord Jesus, body rises out of the water; and into one Spirit with ail the family of God is ha immersed.” (Christian Synem, p. 263. > In other words, we infer that he bsiisvss, with Dr- Richardson in his excel.cut work ■ the Spirit, that the haute ■

act,’ soul

the Spirit, that the batiism of the Holy Spirit ia not limited to the Apogtolic age, but is enjoyed by all Christians who receive the Holy Spirit. This, too, >s s difference pot about s tact, but about ths name ofthe fact. Al! agree that th* spirit of s Christian to-day should be under the influence ofthe Holy Spirit, but whether that is ail that is conveyed by the baptitm of th# Spirit is the point of difference. Is it a very

serious one?

does not deny SI Also tee “satis action” theory as umally stated? H*ve w* ever emulated an article oi faith on s theory of the atonement? No doubt Prolessor Garvin believes that Jesus Ctirist “tasted death lor every men,” that “by His sfrines we *-e healed." “in Him wa have tho rtdemptU , even tbs forgiveness of sins.” snd sli other scriptural statement* on the subisot. The bent and ablest men in Chrirtendom have held different theories of ths atonement, whiio

see the ground op which

lorUsrvin should be eskod to resign his position in tbe Bible denertment or Butler. Are we not large enough, tolerant enough and sufficiently loyal to our own plea, to have Rihi* with variant iheolotflC&l Views

This is the

The inspectors of the different polling places in the West Indianapolis election of Tuesday met last night to canvass the vote. The following are th# official returns for the ticket-at-iarge, the figures being both for the short term and long term of office: I umi, R., mayor, 734 - 711; Carson,

I)., mayor, 672-t>4#; Tolin’i plurality, j pretations, was obligated by the charter of 52-63. Williamson, Ii.,clerk, 745-743; Losh, ! the university to follow the Bible instead of D. t clerk, 607-605; Williamson’s plurality, ( the preference# of missioDary societies or

Bible colleees with variant while hoidin * “ — '

question wbi

TRE COMMITTEE’S CONCLUSION.

The committee, after an interchange of views, adopted the following resolution as

its report to the hoard of directors:

Resolved, Tbat tot*committee finds nothing in the present situation requiring the action ot

tee board.

Members of tbe college board cite the fact that Garvin, in making his scriptural inter-

138-138. Hoss, K., treasurer, 745-73t>; Hag- ! erdorn, D., treasurer, 617-613; Hass’* plu- ‘ rulity, 128-136. Perry, R., marshal, 733-734; , Hhaier, D., marshal, 634-627; Perry’s plu-

rality, 99-107.

This is the largest vote that has ever been j cast in the suburb. It evidently shows that ; a large number of people did not knowhow 1 to vote with the ballots, that varied a little | from the usual ones, f or instance, twenty-1 four men voted for Carson for the short ; term of office, which extends to September, : but evidently did not see that bis nama appeared again immediately underneath for the four-year term. The great majority of voters avoided this confusion by stamping

the straight ticket.

The vote at last year’s election wa*: For trustee, Tolin, 547; Hagerdorn, 584; fur oierk. Finch, 533; Keeler, 52to for treasurer, Johnson, 540; Jennings, 529; for mar-

shal, Maholm. 488: Ready. 463.

Kx-Uarshal Maholm states his intention of testing Tuesday’s election in the courts in euu*e of Uie alleged illegality of placing the candidate* for both the short and tbe long terms of office on the same ballot

preachers in convention. The aection of the charter cited includes this as one of the objects of the coliege: “To teach and inculcate the Christian faith and Christian morality, as taught in the sacred scriptures, discarding as uninspired and without authority all writings, formulas, creeds and articles of faith subsequent thereto." The college committee’s report will be presented to tbe college board at its meeting in June, and the present indications are favorable to a harmonious subsidsno*

of the controversy.

— -W-- - ART SCHOOL DlRECTORS.

Annual Meeting and Election of Inst raotora—The finbKori prion Lint.

The directors of the Indiana School of Art have begun preparations for the continuance of the school for another period of three years. The annual meeting of subscribers will take place on Tuesday, May 8, at 4 o’clock, at which time three directors are to be elected. Th# attendance has steadily increased, and was larger last year than since tee organization of the school.

To Discuss the S. cwnrt Affair. VPi

The colored people of tha city will meet ! Mr. Forsyth will continue with the schuol, at the Ninth Presbyterian church, Michigan ®fld Mr, Steele has also accepted nn and Tennessee streets, Monday night to engagement to begin with the next year

•ffiMr. j next November. Miss Robinson has been

continued, and other teacher* will be ear

Highest of all in Leavening Power.-

Mrs. Frank Ader, of Greenoastle, said it was a deplorable thing that the pari had no newspaper correspondents. The absence of these gave the historian’s imagination untrammeled play, and he was undisturbed in his «reating of gods and demi-goda. She said the greatest aseiatent to the historian of tho fntora would no tho newspaper eer*

C. th ST? THE EMALLPOXT

State Officiate Otwiagr it Attention—Randall’* Army. The smallpox is receiving serious consideration from Governor Matthews nod tho The psopis *f that eeotion have been somewhat uneasy, fearing that when the Commonweal army loft Uhie^o and crossed too State, the disease might bo anted in ita spread. Tho pooplo wanted the authorities to pr«v«nt too army from entering the Nt«to, and naked too Governor to issue a proclamation. Tho State board had ordered that all the armies be vaccinated, sad, as te* cittes oa to* here den have i>eea enforcing tbe rule, it waa •totted with, tbe Indiana board asking that the Ghios^o army be properly looked^after before being allowed to enter thie State. The army it now in Indiana, and the lllinoie board has not bean heard from. Th* State Board ef Health does not know that .Randall’s army ha* beenYaocinsted. but it probably ha* not It should havo been inquired into at Hammond, where the army entered tho State, bat * * thinks, bus been neglected.

Eddx-flsroet Quarantine Roieed. The quarantine at 40 Eddy etreet woo raised at noon to-day and the ninetofn people who have been confined in tho boose for three weeks were released. No evP deuce of smallpox was shown. The patients at the nestehoase have shoal recovered and are able to walk around. World’s rate Couimttiee Meeting. The executive committee of the Indiana World’s Fair Commission will probably bold » meeting at the dtate Uoaee next week. The Ret of awards to Indiana exhibitors will be reported, and the final tinanoiai statement made.

MWJ.

Funeral notice later. AYRES j*n* a. died Tbersdap. Key a.MPL axv Meventy-ntu* year*. Funeral Oauirdsy, 1:00 P- «»•. from family residence, east ol otty LINDER—Howard, lota ol Indiaaopoli*, at tSTYUtfS. S&iiSlsjSHj: residence. No UMO N. Tvnnoreee st.. of heart ()tevs*e, in her forty ninth year. Notice of funeral _ HANRAHAN—John V., died Thursday. May 8. 1804. at 1 a m , as* 88 years, at rrafdenoe, 83 Chadwick at. Funeral at bouse, Metc&. M ftlra3i T *' 8 * nrlc, ■ ** *t John’s

rare ar eiiankw.

We desire to thank tfie sererel l< many friends who gave us thetr tym attention durln —’

our mother, Jow

w ho gave us their lymwilEy and ■ ng thh lost sickness sad death of

ir mother, Joeenhiue UiU.

From her children

JOHN GILL, bister and Hrotbeae.

FUNF.HAL PIPKCTOHE.

jpuNRRAL Di*serous— a U K EEGgur A (i W ■ ZTUTT. CHARLES tTwHITBETT Residence Deolson House Private ’plfon*670

monument**

Af oxt:tixnt*—AT LOWEST FAIOEfi. K.H. zU FARHKLL. 20H W. Washington st \| ONUMRMTS-AUU. DIKNER.848 B. WASHiU Ington. Branch east entrants |o Ora wo Hill.

jisigasst.

palmistry

oeota

mr. May Bmm

pUyscbometry. Admission

'■•-e-" -* •— tv-er-. ■w.«ei»|. iwi,i.ijAii. in ^.e’aieieiiyrai'tfetie^ilwysgdlBfesillliisrasisw^wiieW

L OF L F.-THE MKKBKRb OF

oilge, No. ~ ~ ' ^ -

Sg

_. i brother, Je. , .

ralis«. HKNRY SINE, Master.

WJ§. ?. HUGO. Secretary.

uoiitnrv—fiTATKD MEETING OF LOG AM O lArige. No. 5(8, f. A. M . this Thursday} evening at 8 o'olcu it. Luslnres of Importance te

come before tbe lodae. KalllnCIs

O. C. BIT

H. J. JACOBSEN, fisc-y.

cocun-r-oUkEN eetheh chapter, mo. O 8, O. K. ». Slaied meeting of 4ut>«u Father

s^r.tv&ris. ’fa*

NATHALIE Cv>NNELLY, W. M. NETTIE KAMMFUHP, Secretary.

of Importance t iti-Ir IrM.'

VodiTk.

^>(m iki v- M ASONH.’ -FKNTALl'HA

» No. 5tt4, F. snd A, M stated meeting I Masonic Temple this fTbnrsdayi evrofos St O’clock : also work In the second degree Vitfrai wel. ome. C\ L. HUTtTf INfiOM, W. M.

WILLIAM H. 8MYTflE. fieoretary,

CuflOTY-K OFF. -tA l) IA N A I’OJ.IH LODti 4 C? meets In regular oonvestfon this (Thursday) evening, 7:45 o'clock Work In pas# rank. Lodge meets In Journal Building. Taka elevator.

Visitors welcome.

At lest: W. H BUDD.CO. <>Ki >. T. BREUMIQ. K. B. and 8.

ltd lift Ii Ati AN Ir LOAN ASM#.

TprTufo u&'iMWjtiarn Jr Vance Block. Free en I ranee. vVriLiiiNo Ajfn Los * —BUil.Ift NO APFOCfrAJ> tiou sliares purchased. 81 Virginia ave. l>i:i|.Dtxo*v«Loas—BtifIXj) 1NU AND LOAN Jr oMtooiatfon shares purchased. Room 34 fa-

galls Klock.

fiuir.MiKo ami. Loam—COLUMBIA. 78 L) Market, fiend two-oent stamp and get 1 “Llfo Lessons.” f)tni.l>iwa AXJ> Loan—SUMS 8500 TO f -L» 7 per cent Interest: straight loans. Mi'W H1HTER. 74 E Market

jSun.niBO AV.n Lsaw-—THE ROOMIER I8SUK8

L* a | sip pi an

liuiLPiNOAXi» Loam—THE UNION MUTUAL

Ir Bulkllni

new scries May 7- Meets corner Missis* md Vermont sts. every Monday fvapteg.

Loas—THE UNJON MUTUAL

*r Building and Los 11 Association Loans 10ode Without delsr. omen Mo. Pennsylvania st.

tuiLUirra and

mmmi

|-Ruiipiwo". LOAM-OERMAM AMERICAN i) liUiLO Mi# AMfiOCIATlON. Loans made without deisy, ALHKRT fiAHM. Treasurer, u w, BitoWM. fiocretary. io Boston mock

Spp -itery. MO E. Market st.

19 per cent, per snautn dlvlden't 1 ** * ro * B’ NKW°YKaI ha Vf*?! AN fr^lAW -M-M JL W S Mb A K W A V A.W A la U 1 t eJCI vV* Washington, room C; take stock any dsyissve

'g^uiifoiNt

Ml saeiTABLi

ng and Loan Association pay* M

■ » paid-up stock and 91 per ran* os

But an D Loan—THE

per cent, tn

BlMHt. ■ rower* and investor* that no can; money op band. Call for HOWARD KIMBALL. Bseretary, street iJl'ILDINO AMD LOA.V—1 Jr large sum of home ft be loaned In sums ol ward, at lowest rates money same please, a.

B“s; CIATlOf